Strike: labor, unions, and resistance in the Roman Empire
Bond, S. E. (2026). Strike: labor, unions, and resistance in the Roman Empire. Yale University Press.
Contents
Acknowledgments - ix
Maps - xii
Introduction: Striking from the Record - 1
1. The Plebs, Secession, and Military Strikes - 21
2. We Are Spartacus: Labor and Resistance in the Late Republic - 44
3 Freedom of Assembly during the Fall of the Republic - 72
4 Anxiety and Associations in the Early Roman Empire - 88
5 Strikes, Riots, and Associations in the Roman Imperial Period - 110
6 Castes, Law, and Compulsory Labor in Late Antiquity - 132
7 Athletic Factions and Popular Rebellion - 156
Conclusion: Uniting Ancient and Modern Laborers - 181
Notes - 189
Bibliography - 219
Index - 241
Introduction: Striking from the Record
In April of 1768, frustrated British sailors working in the busy Port of Sunderland in northern Britain lowered, or "struck," the topsails of the merchant ships docked there. The sailors were in pursuit of higher wages and, by striking the sails, they prevented the vessels from leaving the port. With the trade hub brought to a standstill, shipowners faced the prospect of their dwindling economic might. Across many areas of the British labor force, workers were dissatisfied, restless, and looking for a way to acquire higher pay for their work. The shipowners quickly consented to a pay raise for the sailors who, in turn, restored the sails. By May, another group of sailors, this time along London's Thames River, followed the lead of the Sunderland sailors. Petitioning Parliament and the lord mayor for their own pay raise, the sailors struck the sails of the ships along the bustling Thames. This second striking of the sails delivered the term "strike" into modern usage as a reference to labor-related protests. But while the usage was new, the action was not. Workers had been withholding their labor as a form of protest and as a collective negotiation method for thousands of years.
Over three thousand years earlier, in 1157 or 1155 BCE, necropolis workers and artisans in the Egyptian town of Deir el-Medina were growing tired of late wage payments and declining rations. Twenty-nine years of foreign military exploits by the pharaoh Ramses III had taken their toll on the home front. The tomb-builders and craftspeople laid down their tools, walked off the job, and gathered for a sit-in outside various temples. They withheld their skills during various successive labor strikes as they bargained for better working conditions, eventually extracting timely payments of emmer and other staples from the pharaoh. The actions of the Deir el-Medina workers can (and have been) variously described as a work stoppage, a turnout, a temporary secession, a withdrawal, a walkout, a grève, a strike, and many other terms in other contexts and languages. Regardless of the terminology, the history of collectives of workers strategically withholding their labor extends back to antiquity.
While we may not often hear the artisans of Deir el-Medina compared to the sailors of Sunderland, they and the Roman workers focused on in this book – had plenty in common. Critical examinations of more recent labor strikes scarcely look past the Industrial Revolution for comparisons. And yet, in antiquity and today, the revoking of labor, goods, or services in protest has been a means of achieving a fiscal or environmental shift in working conditions. These shared strategies and tactics lie at the heart of this book, as I examine how workers organized themselves, formally and informally, to navigate labor conflicts. In the process, we may trace more common threads of collective action among all workers, from ancient Egypt to Rome to eighteenth-century England to today.
The labor upheavals in Britain during the eighteenth century did more than just gift us the modern term "strike." Those sailors provided us with one of many data points in the broader history of workers. Their actions bring the social and economic impacts of labor organization into focus and allow us to parse how laborers wielded their power-particularly in the face of governmental authority. For these sailors were not alone in their complaints. At the same time that they were striking the sails of merchant ships, British journeyman groups made up of artisans and craftsmen began to mobilize across the country, often meeting in pubs, and organizing into "friendly societies" (a sort of union precursor) for monthly meetings. Like many ancient associations, these societies charged dues, provided burial and sickness insurance, created camaraderie through leisure events, and consolidated political advocacy among their members. Despite the benefits these societies provided to workers, many business owners and the British government itself failed to see them as friendly.
Because these groups could disrupt both commerce and civic order, the British government increasingly tried to use legislation to cap the workers' growing power and limit the use of strikes for higher wages. Frequently, the government enacted anti-conspiracy laws to prosecute and ban such actions by certain trade groups. Hatters, shoemakers, tailors, and weavers-among many others could be tried as "conspirators" against their employers or prosecuted as members of illegal secret societies. New laws and legal precedents seemingly provided the government with the legal tools to curtail future economic disruptions. These laws, which redefined oaths, clandestine meetings, and collective action as conspiracies, became a crucial tactic for the government as it sought to combat the rise of trade unionism into the early nineteenth century. American courts, companies, and political constituencies were paying attention, and similar laws were soon in place across the Atlantic. This was not the first time that labor collectives had been cast as conspirators. Across another ocean of time, Roman elites had recast private groups such as the worshippers of Bacchus and even provincial fire brigades as possible threats to the civic order to prevent social or economic disruptions.
The historically long practice of governments using legislation to limit people's ability to congregate is commonly known as anti-assembly legislation. For reasons realistic or invented, defensive or opportunistic, a government labels certain collectives as conspiratorial, seditious, or perhaps criminal. Once branded as a threat, these groups find themselves subject to new legislation designed to hem in or prevent their actions. As early as 186 BCE, elite Roman senators and magistrates in the middle Republic took issue with the religious cults dedicated to Bacchus, the Greek god of wine and vegetation. Labeling the worshipers a drunken threat to public order and a foreign threat to Roman religion, the elites used their rhetorical skills and legal powers to craft new laws largely banning the assembly of Bacchic worshippers without special permission.
But religious cults were not the only target for such Roman laws. In 64 BCE, during the political tumult of the late Republic and in the midst of a rising tide of populism, the Roman Senate again began to use similar language and present legal justifications to halt the meetings of ambiguously defined collectives called collegia (associations). Roman elites began to fear popular action and the political sway built through collegia, which dangerously empowered the citizenry. Laws prohibiting assemblies in the Roman Mediterranean sprung up ostensibly to stop these groups from threatening the so-called civic interests of the Republic. Such legislation against formal and informal collectives and their actions is evident from the late Roman Republic well into the period we call late antiquity (200-800 CE). The people these laws targeted, and the elite politicians who tried to stymie their collective power, are the main characters of this book.
Ancient peoples created their own collectives for a range of religious, social, and occupational purposes. These groups included persons engaged in shared crafts and business pursuits. The Roman world was already filled with thousands of collectives across the Mediterranean and beyond. Formal membership in a collective was not required to participate in labor conflicts. There were, however, some benefits to joining formal groups. They could often organize and mobilize members more quickly. They also could rally associates to back the election of magistrates who would, in turn, support them economically and socially in their businesses. Graffiti at Pompeii show artisan collectives such as goldsmiths haranguing the people to vote for a man named Gaius Cuspius Pansa for a position as a market overseer called an aedile. Just like today, having politicians in your corner who might support your workshop, or even look the other way in the forum, if need be, was important to trade collectives. Some of these groups had charters, dues, and swanky clubhouses, while others were less official and lacking the funds and written regulations of the more well-known associations. These ancient associations-whether a collective of enslaved and freed tent-makers in Rome or a group of purple-dye sellers gathering at Thessalonica in Roman Macedonia-often (but not always) shared a common trade, profession, or industry.
Roman collectives mattered to the people who joined them. That much is clear in the historical record purely in terms of the frequency with which they are mentioned on epitaphs and in letters, monuments, statues, and graffiti. A more granular reading of each of these groups the particulars of their membership, the structures of their governance, their services, meeting spaces, and social impactis harder to pin down. Perhaps as little as 4 percent of the writings from the ancient world have survived through to our contemporary moment. When we begin the work of reconstructing ancient history, we must acknowledge that we are working with largely fragmented and biased sources from antiquity. And, as many modern scholars studying Roman associations have noted, most collegia and their ilk were ignored by contemporary aristocratic literati even in their own day. Writers such as Livy or Tacitus tended to provide upperclass audiences with elite accounts of Roman history. In turn, these sources were then relied upon to tell the story of Rome we know today. As a result, ancient historians hoping to recover the daily lives of regular Romans and their associations from the Iberian peninsula to Syria have had to use different types of written sources. Inscriptions, papyri, graffiti, archaeological remains, and non-narrative writings often help social historians to reconstruct the dynamic reality of these groups and their significance to many everyday Romans.
But how many of these groups were there? Digital projects have collected data for over 3200 Greek, Roman, and Hellenistic associations from 500 BCE to 300 CE; this is likely just a fraction of the ones that existed. Despite the often-fragmented evidence for the existence of these associations, to omit them from our analyses in the present would be, as archaeologist Francesca Diosono rightly argues, to leave out a fundamental element of the society, economy, and legacy of the Roman Mediterranean. These small but essential social units were capable of providing financial and social support, local prestige, reputation, and networks of trust to thousands in a society that largely rejected the funding of state welfare programs and social safety nets. The silencing of their story by aristocratic writers leaves a devasting gap in our understanding of that society. These fragmentary sources help return the voice of collective action to a conversation about labor in the ancient world.
Recovering a History from Below for Ancient Collectives and Their Actions
All historical narratives leave things out. Historians-both today and in antiquity-make decisions about what to include and exclude in service to the story they are telling. And those choices often tell us a lot about the authors and their audiences. For many Roman authors writing in antiquity, associations, trade, the everyday lives of enslaved or freedpersons, and even small-scale civic disruptions such as strikes were not the sort of fodder they regularly deigned to record. The imperial historian and statesman Tacitus chose to gloss over details concerning Nero's building of a wooden amphi-theater in 57 CE in Rome's Campus Martius. The historian defended this exclusion by noting that it suited the dignity of the Roman people to record only "illustrious matters" in the pages of his Annals and to leave petty, quotidian matters, such as the amphitheater construction, to the city's daily register. Tacitus's conviction was clear: to be worthy of being recorded in the annals of history, a thing or a person had to have a certain level of dignity.
Dignity and reputation were difficult things to come by in Roman antiquity. Social currency was not available to all, and Romans rarely granted such auspicious trappings to manual laborers and tradespeople. Deprived of that elevated status, those workers were kept on the sidelines of the triumphal narrative created for Rome. On those rare occasions when ancient writers included mention of the less dignified classes, they often did so to demonstrate the character of an individual, rather than as a means of recording the lives of regular Romans. For instance, Tacitus's contemporary, the writer and biographer Suetonius, commented more extensively on the building of the same Neronian amphitheater in his biography of the emperor. In Suetonius's telling, Nero forced numerous senators and equestrians to fight as disreputable gladiators within the new arena. For Suetonius, the issues of financing the project, the organization of the construction workers, and the lives of the artisans who built the amphitheater were irrelevant. What did bear noting was the stigma Nero subjected the more elite Romans to by casting them as gladiators. In Roman law, such gladiators carried a stigma called infamia (infamy), which rendered them legally and socially marginalized. Suetonius uses this tale of the undignified to throw Nero's true nature into relief. His mention of the amphitheater in Nero's biography was a way to demonstrate how the emperor degraded elites.
In an ancient Mediterranean world where history and biography were meant to be largely educational and to provide moral examples, daily life was all too often ignored unless it served a satirical, instructional, or moralistic purpose. This tendency of historians in antiquity to omit daily life makes it difficult to provide an account of the histories of ordinary people. What we today call a "history from below"-privileging those stories of regular folks over the lives of the elite-would have been an undignified, ignoble, and boring endeavor to Tacitus. But Tacitus is not writing this book. As many historians of the ancient world have done in the past century, we can revise our definitions of the discipline and, most importantly, of who deserves the dignity of inclusion. Today, we want to peer more closely into the daily lives of regular Romans. This book is an effort to recover the histories of ancient labor organization, mobilization, and resistance from below in the Roman Mediterranean from 509 BCE until 565 CE.
In this book, I tell the stories of Roman laborers, their associations, and their labor conflicts alongside the traditional, canonical story of Rome's emperors and political power players. In doing so, I am revising the all-too-familiar story of a village that became an empire and restoring to it some important context. In this telling, workers star alongside emperors. As we move through the book, we will track the volatile ways in which the state used its own tools of enforcement as a means of keeping certain collectives from assembling, growing, organizing, and challenging its own authority. These strategies will be familiar to many today: the use of police forces and soldiers to squelch popular movements, the operations of state surveillance, and the passing of anti-assembly legislation under the guise of patriotism. From the plebeians who withheld military service during the so-called Struggle of the Orders (c. 495-287 BCE) to the political advocacy of charioteer factions in late antiquity, we will see that where there was collective action from below, there would often be a civic or state reaction from above.
Historiography on Roman Strikes and the Roles of Associations
The work stoppage of the Egyptian necropolis workers in 1157 or 1155 BCE is today often viewed as the first instance of a rare event in antiquity: an ancient strike. If the withholding of labor in protest is mentioned, such actions are often cast as broadly uncharacteristic of ancient labor collectives-and particularly atypical of Roman workforces. The possible exception to this tendency was nineteenth-century Marxist analyses of the sociopolitical conflict between the plebeians and patricians of Rome during the Struggle of the Orders. At the beginning of The Communist Manifesto (issued in 1848), Friedrich Engels and Karl Marx cited this multi-century conflict between plebeians and patricians as a fundamental example of how all history was a history of class struggles. Most historians today rightly recognize that the plebeians did not constitute a unified social class in the modern sense; however, Engels and Marx were correct that secession and the withholding of military service by many Roman plebeians were pivotal as leverage for their demands. In many ways, their tactics are analogous to the modern use of strikes to force negotiation.
Most scholars have viewed strikes as seldom, if ever, occurring in antiquity and only genuinely taking off with the rise of modern capitalism. Influential early twentieth-century scholars of ancient economies such as Tenney Frank believed a lack of strikes was the result of Romans using enslaved labor and, later, the Roman dependence on compulsory, staterun occupational associations in the period known as late antiquity. Other scholars, such as famed historian and archaeologist Mikhail Ivanovich Rostovtzeff, noted the existence of strikes in antiquity but blamed a "low standard of industry" for their infrequency rather than Rome's use of enslaved laborers. I argue, quite to the contrary, that enslaved laborers not only engaged in labor conflicts and small, everyday acts of rebellion, but at various points also took part in and drove strikes, well into the period of the late Roman Empire. Less commonly, but no less effectively, participants in state-run associations also used or threatened to use such tactics. If we look to the shipowners of Arles in the late second to early third century CE, or the mint workers under Aurelian in the late third century CE, we can see that these artisans, too, could resist Rome.
How, then, do we explain the relative dearth of evidence for regularized strikes in Roman antiquity? The bleak survival rates of texts and Roman literary biases may carry some blame. Part of the issue may also be the manner in which Roman crowds were described. Many ancient accounts of public violence over commercial matters cast groups broadly as a turba (crowd) or nameless multitude. Then as today, presenting mass movements in a city as an unruly and dangerous mob moralizes, but also revokes, the validity of popular causes. Whether deployed by Cicero in antiquity or by political pundits today, the rhetoric of uncontrolled "mob" violence helps marginalize a group and rob it of its ideologies, intents, and legitimacy. Cicero knew this when in 61 BCE he characterized the followers of the later triumvir Pompey who attended his political speeches as a miserable and starving mob. And we might detect similar tactics at play in today's news media.
But the reach of such pejorative language can extend much further than singular instances of public, popular action. This speech can also obscure the underlying structures, hierarchies, and intents of social movements. In his assessment of the modern rhetoric surrounding crowds engaged in collective action, social psychologist John Drury argues, "The delegitimizing functions of such negative language and explanations are obvious. If the crowd is pathologized and criminalized, then its behaviour is not meaningful." The largely scornful accounts of Roman crowds and their conduct only rarely mention the subunit of occupational associations, and only when it is to disparage the artisans who participated. These characterizations, in turn, may have fed the doubts of Frank and many other economic historians reading with the grain of Roman texts, and influenced their belief that collectives did not have the ability or economic interest to mobilize a strike or call for work stoppages in service to higher wages or better working conditions.
The earlier doubts about the economic aptitude or ability of ancient associations were later echoed by prominent Roman social historians, up through today. Ancient writings' elisions and aversions concerning the economic capacity of associations have undoubtedly colored our contemporary approach to the subject matter. And while the absence of a cohesive narrative about organized labor in antiquity might be staring us in the face, historians have been understandably hesitant to fill that void. Historians harbor a deep-seated and reasonable nervousness about anachronism. We hesitate to cast the ancient world in contemporary terms for fear of appearing to puppeteer history. As a result, we might acknowledge the historical fact of labor riots or protests but fall short of ascribing the words "labor union" to their actors.
Yet metaphors and analogies can help us apprehend those actions and actors. Although most Roman associations did not function as modern labor unions that could advocate for wages, rights, or working conditions, some did; and that fact deserves to be more resolutely underscored and connected to the present. While the blanket label of "labor union" for all associations has rightly given most ancient historians pause, for fear of projecting the present onto the past, a growing contingent of scholars see the necessity of applying modern terms to the past, with nuance and care, if all criteria are met. Underscoring some of the similarities between ancient and modern unions may also dispel lingering notions of the primitive nature of the Roman economy.
I will here admit to committing to a "strategic anachronism" by applying the term "labor union" to certain ancient Roman associations, particularly to the ancient artists of Dionysus and the athletic unions that appear most akin to labor unions today. This calculated analogy allows us to speak to the present and to capture both the continuities and functional differences of occupational groups who advocated for their members over the longue durée. The merging of terminology can also encourage more engagement in comparative history. Orlando Patterson's cross-comparison of sixty-six different slaveholding societies further developed the global sociological concept of "social death" across time and space. And while critics of Patterson and others engaged in comparative histories of servitude continue to reappraise and tweak his influential model, his comparative methods usefully put different historical time periods into conversation with each other.
Historical comparison often helps us understand the experience of alterity. Similarly, I argue in this book that coping mechanisms such as group formation might be best understood through this approach. Patterson's unprecedented efforts to understand the tactics of marginalization enacted by enslavers revealed that we cannot let excessive trepidation over the cardinal sin of historical anachronism keep us from engaging with the ancient world in all its complexity and connecting it with the present. Whether examining an association of Jews persecuted in Alexandria in the first century CE or the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters in New York City in 1925, the united study of such groups can allow us to see the social and economic reasons that have caused marginalized humans to come together-and why those in power so often view these alliances as a threat. It is no accident that Black workers have the highest unionization rates in America today. Collectivization often increases equity and access to social and financial benefits in important ways. There are strong parallels to be (carefully) drawn between antiquity and the modern world in terms of this deeply human impulse to come together. These similarities can open necessary dialogues among labor historians from all times and places who seek to identify the historical and present advantages in the plural over the singular.
Defining the Ancient Association
In this book, I scrutinize the component parts of Roman labor and its organization into public and private associations over many successive centuries, examining the impact of hundreds of workers and the ways they came together between 509 BCE and 565 CE. Workers, professionals, and business-people belonged to numerous types of Mediterranean associations that went by many names: collegia, sodalitates, hetaireiai, thiasoi, synodoi, corpora, koina, and synagogai, among others. Other groups simply used collective nouns like "the bakers," from which we can infer various co-ops. Not all of these collectives were alike. Each association was in many ways unique. But many of these known groups also shared commonalities in terms of function, membership, dues, services, and state regulation. Modern scholars classify many of these groups according to these variations in nomenclature and associative attributes, typically remarked on in existing inscriptions or papyri. In this book, I take that typology a step further and label at least some of these groups as comparable to labor unions.
Named groups of laborers, artisans, merchants, and other commercial agents are often referred to in English as occupational guilds. Although many scholars today associate guilds with monopolistic economic behaviors and price controls, the leading scholar on the medieval guild, Sheilagh Ogilvie, has shown that it was in fact a broad and extremely flexible concept: A guildin its most general form-is an association of people who share some common characteristic and pursue some common purpose. In this study, I have chosen not to adopt the term "guild" for Roman artisan, merchant, or occupational associations, so as not to further complicate the terminology.
As Ogilvie suggests, the guild was also an association with varying degrees of structure and formality. Like a Roman association, they were often a deeply meaningful part of daily life for many living in medieval Europe and cannot be spoken of as a homogenous type.
The choice to underscore the similarities between modern labor unions and Roman associations in this book is meant to be both provocative and unifying. The analogy challenges labor historians of the modern era to engage with Roman antiquity in more meaningful ways, rather than seeing labor organization, collective actions, economic networks, and unionizing behaviors such as wage bargaining or contract negotiations as solely progressive products of modern capitalism. The strategic anachronism is a challenge to the notion that labor unions were a modern or extraordinary product of the Industrial Revolution in Europe. Historians of Europe and America focused on labor from the eighteenth to the twentieth centuries continue to portray the labor union as a modern invention created by workers from below in order to provide them with new methods for achieving economic empowerment. While medieval guilds are frequently identified as the progenitor of these modern labor unions, Roman associations get less credit for their economic capabilities, their advocacy for members, their political influence, or their ability to provoke strikes. This artificial origin story for the birth of the modern labor union supports a philosophy of exceptionalism that simply is not the full truth, and one that ancient Roman historians have, in the past three decades of important but less popularly recognized work, begun to erode.
The refusal to see ancient associations as akin to modern labor unions has a long history. The repudiation goes back to the European economists and social reformers of the late nineteenth century. In 1870, German economist Lujo Brentano argued instead for the connections between the modern labor union and the medieval guild; he represented the early modern associations of journeymen, which emerged as medieval guild protections were disintegrating, as the pivotal link between the two collectives. For Brentano and many others, the preindustrial journeyman associations walked so that the labor unions could run. Interest in Roman collegia arose at about the same time, following classicist and epigrapher Theodor Mommsen's magisterial publication of Latin inscriptions in 1862, many of which revealed evidence for the myriad Roman associations not mentioned in the literary record. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, Belgian epigrapher Jean-Pierre Waltzing would argue in his extensive works that Roman associations were social in form and function. Most scholars viewed ancient associations (as well as the Roman economy) through a simplistic, two-dimensional lens that cast social purposes such as feasting and burial as their raison d'être.
This view of Roman associations held sway into the mid-twentieth century. Ancient economist Moses Finley hated anachronisms and saw medieval guilds as more developed and economically capable than the earlier Roman collegia. He firmly stated, "Not only were there no Guildhalls in antiquity, there were no guilds, no matter how often the Roman collegia and their differently named Greek and Hellenistic counterparts are thus mistranslated." Seconding Finley's disdain for perceived anachronism, Ramsay MacMullen would claim that collegia were social rather than economic entities – a view then blithely repeated by many scholars thereafter. MacMullen's characterization of collegia as mere social clubs informed his assertion that he and other scholars could find "close to no" evidence of strikes in antiquity. For many, Roman associations were merely confraternities formed largely for feasting, burial insurance, community, and religious worship.
In the past two decades, analysis of the economic roles of Greco-Roman associations has greatly increased and made our understanding of their formation and impact much more dynamic. A new generation of scholars studying these collectives and their dynamic characteristics has shown that a Roman association could serve both social and economic functions. Two things may, in fact, be true at once. Ancient associations could provide spaces for social interaction in pubs or clubhouses, opportunities for dining together at convivial meetings, and other means of fostering social relations. At the same time, they could also serve the economic and professional interests of their members, if need be, just as modern labor unions of teamsters, dock-workers, and welders do today. The false binary applied to the classification of the ancient versus the modern association-one for play or worship, the other for work-collapses as soon as one begins to read the charters of many Roman associations. These guiding documents frequently intermix concerns over credit and prices with stipulations about membership dues, monthly feasts, and burial policies. We ought not rob the people of antiquity of their complexity or their ability to create multidimensional associative bodies.
A desire for identity, purpose, and access to exclusive economic networks that provided stability and trust were the impetus for establishing many such groups for centuries within the ancient world, far outside of just Roman culture. But there are also many differences between the past and the present to tease out. Unlike labor unions today, some associations in antiquity were imposed and overseen by the state as a means of control and a way to secure supply chains. These compulsory groups were usually called corpora and fell along a spectrum of intervention and regulation developed by the state in the late Roman Empire. Romans also had associations that formed organically, outside of state imposition. These were formed by workers, artisans, merchants, professionals like doctors and architects, and by wealthier businesspeople too.
To tell the story of these groups, their influence, and their actions in Roman history, we need to start with the mythical origins of these groups. This means the stories that Romans in the late Republic, seven hundred years after the alleged founding of Rome, told themselves about the nascence of occupational collegia, which many believed Rome's kings had formed many hundreds of years prior. These legends may not be historically accurate, but they are lore that reveal Roman attitudes and anxieties surrounding these groups. These stories also illustrate the Roman preference for a local tradition rooted in the ways of the ancestors over newfangled or foreign mores. Finally, read-ing about the later fabulations concerning the early years of Rome might give us one explanation for how later Romans understood when and why trades-people were first placed into their own associations based on their professional skills.
Myths and Labor Organization in the Rome of the Early Kings
The city of Rome enjoys a number of legendary origin stories. Chief among these is that Romulus founded the city known in Latin as Roma along the banks of the Tiber River on April 21, 753 BCE. Later tales of the seven early kings of Rome credit not Romulus, but rather the second king, Numa Pompilius (r. 716-674 BCE), with founding Rome's first occupational associations. These tales often suggest that it was Numa who organized the early Romans into groups based on their trade. The early imperial biographer Plutarch stated that Numa had distributed the populace into groups according to their artisan skills: "musicians, goldsmiths, carpenters, dyers, leather-workers, leather curriers, coppersmiths, and potters. The remaining arts, he gathered together into one corps out of all who belonged to this group. He also dictated associations and assemblies and rites of worship rendered to each association."
Despite Plutarch's seeming confidence in the details of the regal period (c. 753-509 BCE), much remains murky about the timing and exact details of events involving these early kings-and how much is myth rather than historical fact. Romans later used the origin stories about this period to explain the ensuing labor taxonomies that structured and helped define the populace in the late Republic. And while the stories of the early kings are not always verifiable, and are often strategic memories of a valiant past, these fables do help us understand how later Romans in the Republic may have conceptualized Rome's beginnings and its social makeup. The stories surrounding Numa's creation of artisan associations also shed light on how elite Romans justified late Republican and early imperial legislation. Those laws used the perceived antiquity of a group going back to the age of Numa, as well as their public utility, as a litmus test for whether such workers were allowed to assemble in the period of the late first century BCE. In the conservative Roman mindset, there was often a respect for the ancient over the novel way of doing things.
In the past and still today, we tell ourselves stories-about the founding fathers of the United States, say, or about a multinational technology company that began in a humble garage in Palo Alto-in order to explain, romanticize, or parse a moment of crisis or innovation in which we are currently living. Romans living in the late Republic of the second and first centuries BCE turned to tales of Rome's early days to better understand the political tensions of their time. They also may have used them to help explain the demographic mix of peoples engaged in various professions, from farming to goldsmithing. Successive generations of Romans remembered these origin stories, filtered unreliably through monuments and later written down in the histories of men like Lucius Calpurnius Piso in the late second century BCE, and then by Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus in the Augustan era (27 BCE-14 CE). Even ancient authors did not all agree upon the regal involvement in the creation of ancient collegia during the monarchy that controlled Rome from Romulus to Tarquinius Superbus (c. 753-509 BCE), Rome's last king.
The Numa myth took hold in Rome at a time of upheaval on almost every social and political front. This was also a period when, as Emilio Gabba has argued, the abolition of associations was frequently and hotly debated by politicians. In 49 BCE, Julius Caesar crossed the Rubicon with his troops and hastened the further crumbling of Republican conventions. Among many other sweeping changes and new laws thereafter, Caesar would move to draw up legislation in 47 or 46 BCE banning all but the most ancient or useful associations. When he specified "ancient" in these laws, this presumably meant he allowed Numa's original associations or traditional Roman ones. Political leaders were wary of such groups. By around 46 BCE, there had been close to twenty years of upheavals, violence, and collective action by various associations, often in support of populist leaders. Most notorious among these would be the tavern keepers and their support for a man named Clodius, which will be discussed more in Chapter Three.
Associations were integral to the economic health of many ancient cities; however, there was an innate tension between the state and the private association. When Julius Caesar attempted to shore up loyalty for his new regime by dispelling divisive associations and passing a law disbanding all but the most ancient ones, he weaponized the myths of the early kings to justify which associations were ancient and thus legitimate. As we will see, his law was but one example in a long history of efforts to control clubs, associations, and collectives through legal means, manipulating history in the process. Both local and imperial laws formed from the Augustan period onward would showcase imperial angst over associations. Fearing seditious intent, the state attempted to legislate them into submission. And as would be the case over seventeen hundred years later with Britain's sailors, the legal definitions of "sedition" and "conspiracy" lay with the government, rather than with private associations.
From the late Republic onward into the time of the early Principate (133 BCE-37 CE), the myth of the early kings' connection with the first Roman collegia only grew and became more self-serving to Roman emperors. While the myth had variations to it, it always grounded only certain named associations as part of Rome's early history. Sometimes, it was not Numa who granted permission to establish these early trade groups. The historian Lucius Annaeus Florus, who lived and wrote during the reigns of Trajan and Hadrian in the second century CE, claimed that the establishment of associations for craftsmen should be attributed instead to the sixth king of Rome, Servius Tullius. But whether it was Numa or Servius Tullius, what mattered was that there was a regal establishment of particular associations useful to the state. At best, it was a myth that allowed people to understand themselves and their background. At worst, the promotion of this myth may be seen as a political device that justified getting rid of all associations except those that were sufficiently old, Roman, and created by a monarch.
The archaeological record provides a more gradual story for the growth of Roman occupational associations than the legends in Rome's histories. Inscriptions and papyri indicate that in the middle to late Roman Republic, various associations took shape, based on trade, religious worship, drinking, and a host of other activities. These associations flourished in the city of Rome, in Italy, and throughout the provinces of Rome's empire, particularly in the East. Whatever the unifying factor for these social units, most associations had a religious aspect, such as a patron deity. But since each association had its own character and purpose, we cannot simply describe them in a uniform manner. We can, however, see how they often created communities for their members. In setting up their micro-prestige systems, associations often also copied the titles used for Roman state magistrates. Even if you could not be on the local civic council, you might, for instance, hold a position on the board of your local association of construction workers. Feasting was another significant activity for these groups. Associations sometimes held large dinners for their members. This banqueting element was as attractive to members as a private restaurant in a country club or a bar in an Elks Lodge might be today. Eating was an important part of community and identity in antiquity as today, and many more informal associations hung out in taverns and inns to discuss matters over hot food and fermented beverages.
For as much as they cared about the vivacious aspects of life, Romans also cared a great deal about the treatment of the dead. Burial insurance was another appealing reason to join an association. Many provided paying members assurances of a proper burial upon their deaths, often up to a certain distance. An inscription from Lanuvium, an Italian town just southeast of Rome, tells us about the founding of an association dedicated to the worship of the goddess Diana and Hadrian's lover, Antinous. It notes that the association would transport a person's body back for burial up to a maximum of twenty miles. In these agreements, people could even stipulate the cleaning or placing of flowers on a tomb after their death. Roses and violets were popular. Because Rome had only minimal state services, akin to what we might think of as welfare programs, burial costs were the first thing taken from the deceased's legacy-that is, their personal wealth-upon death. Only extremely prestigious men or women received a state funeral paid for by the government. In a culture that greatly valued the observation of funerary rituals for the deceased, joining an association that people paid into guaranteed the proper treatment of their bodies after death and provided peace of mind.
By the middle of the first century BCE, the Mediterranean was teeming with these associations, formed for all kinds of businesses and pleasures.
They were woven into the civic fabric and could establish broader networks of communication and exchange to aid in travel, as did the unions for athletes and entertainers. All manner of private clubs, confraternities, involuntary associations, informal collectives, and formal unions had become common place in the ancient Mediterranean in both the West and the East. Associations were not an innovation limited to Rome and the western Mediterranean. They were characteristic of many societies in the Mediterranean, the Near East, India, China, and beyond in the ancient world. The Romans already knew that the Greeks used civic groups for political canvassing and what we might call lobbying. As one historian remarked about the myriad associations in Athens from the archaic period (c. 800-479 BCE) to the Hellenistic period (323-31 BCE), the complexity of the ancient Greek polis was due in part to an overlapping, living network of associations functioning within it.
In Athens and far beyond it, ancient Greek associations influenced city formation, function, and identity. In the later fourth century BCE, Aristotle painted a rosy scenario for these groups in his Nicomachean Ethics: "But all associations are parts as it were of the association of the State." The philosopher underscored a key aspect of occupational associations by noting their power to mitigate risk; he suggested that in the same the way travelers journeyed together to protect themselves and their possessions, sailors created associations to safeguard seafaring profits, and soldiers banded together in warfare. Historians of the ancient economy have more recently suggested that the trust networks created among many types of associations-for example, the Ptolemaicera (305-30 BCE) religious associations in Hellenistic Egypt could additionally function in an economically positive manner to reduce transaction costs and provide social capital to members. Aristotle noted that associations often formed for religious reasons or for dining parties; still, social networks, ancient or modern, have a way of benefitting their members economically. We might think here of alumni networks that hire young college graduates today as a way to grasp a social association that can and does influence economic choices made by employers. And where social and economic interests coincide, politics are not far behind. For Aristotle, while private associations might have self-interests, they should ideally subordinate those aims to the civic good and political order maintained by the state. For their part, the associations did not always share this communal state-mindedness.
In Classical Athens (479-323 BCE), at about the same time that Rome was beginning its new Republic, membership in a political club was crucial for attaining political clout. Membership could confer authority on non-elites who needed to mobilize members for political support. One famous example of this concerns the fifth-century BCE Athenian naval general and statesman Themistocles. He came from a non-aristocratic background, and so joined an Athenian political club called a hetaireia to enhance his political standing. His more well-born political contemporary, Aristides, viewed membership in political clubs and reliance on one's fellow club members to gain power and exert influence in the polis as corrupt. The use of such clubs was seen as a populist tactic. Greek literature of the time indicates that the civic land-scape of Athens in the archaic period was already dotted with male-only political clubs, used especially to navigate the court system and attain certain state offices. The role and power of these private associations and their members, and the state's desire that the people adhere to its will, required a delicate balance. For the Greeks, as in Roman society, the two camps were not always in agreement.
Ancient laws provide us with one way to examine reactions to the formation of associations as well as state anxieties surrounding their unregulated growth. At the same time, we must keep in mind that-both in the past and in the present there is a wide gap between proscriptive legislation and social reality. Just because a law bans a particular type of association does not mean that these groups did not exist or that the state had enough manpower to enforce such sweeping legislation. Just because a law prohibits jaywalking, this does not mean everyone is only using the crosswalks. But legislation from antiquity can tell us what lawmakers, Roman emperors, provincial governors, town councils, or any other entity that passed legislation aimed at governing voluntary associations hoped to accomplish.
Including Antiquity in Histories of Labor and Collective Action
Our contemporary moment has seen continued debate about many of the issues ancient Romans addressed. The issues of work, trade, and collective action have been part of an international dialogue in the years since the COVID-19 pandemic began. In the American Midwest, meatpacking plants forced migrant workers to work even when sick, and those classified as "essential workers" continued to provide groceries, medical care, and services we had long taken for granted. The pandemic also taught the world a great deal about the global supply chain, chiefly revealing its fragility. The need to secure supply chains by mitigating risk and creating resilience within the system is an ancient idea examined in the pages ahead. In more recent history, dozens of unions were formed in the wake of the labor shake-up that followed the pandemic.
Perhaps the most remarked upon unionization efforts have been the Amazon workers who started a labor union at a warehouse in Staten Island, the wave of museum workers moving to unionize in arts institutions across the United States, and the Ukrainian mining unions working to support the Ukrainian economy in the midst of a Russian invasion. We are now experiencing a new, global labor movement-one that has accentuated the benefits of banding together to address rampant inequality in terms of wages and working conditions. Nothing like this massive new push toward labor unionization and regularized strikes existed in the ancient world on the scale we are now seeing. However, using Roman history to examine the ways in which regular Romans banded together in various forms can give us some empathy and insight into the ways that humans cope with marginalized identities, inequality, a lack of public prestige outlets for non-elites, and socioeconomic uncertainty. The voluntary and involuntary organization of labor into various types of informal collectives, formal associations, and unions supported many of the events, people, and places in Roman history. They influenced Rome's growth in ways we have not fully grasped in traditional histories from above that focus on emperors, elites, and the lives of the wealthy.
Lastly, this book provides a parallel to the modern world by examining Roman state anxieties over labor collectives, strikes, and challenges to state power. Just as is the case today, fear of economic disruptions drove elites and politicians to make choices that suppressed what we might call the freedom of assembly, comparable to modern union-busting legislation. Then and now, such legislation often employed the rhetoric of sedition or conspiracy to mask fears about how collective organization from below might challenge the economic, social, and political interests of the wealthy. From the involuntary associations of gladiatorial familiae that helped to start the Spartacan War from 73 to 71 BCE to the charioteer factions at the heart of the Nika revolt in Constantinople in January of 532 CE, peeling back the layers of Roman social history exposes a vast associative network at work within the Roman Mediterranean. While some preferred only to feast and to quietly bury their dead, other ancient groups engaged in labor conflicts such as strikes, secessions, and rebellion. These actions allowed their voices to be heard by those in power.
Chapter 1
The Plebs, Secession, and Military Strikes
Legend held that Romans founded their republic in 509 BCE. Myths about this era were written down only later, but carried forth harrowing tales of the overthrow of a monarchy and the establishment of a republican government. But the creation of a republic did not create social harmony. Even after the last king of the regal period was allegedly forced into exile, there remained a civil divide within Rome's new state. The senators, called patres (fathers), who made up the Roman Senate and came from the early families of Rome, formed an elite social order called the patricians. These patricians monopolized political and religious power, but there simply were not enough of them to fill the ranks of the Roman army. And, frankly, one gets the feeling that the patricians enjoyed being military officers and generals, but did not particularly like to do the day-to-day grunt work of a regular soldier. Patricians constantly called on the military service of the many male citizens outside their order, called the plebeians, instead. Over and over, these plebeians were asked to re-enlist in the ranks of the army and fight in an increasing number of wars against local Italian tribes. The problem was that when these plebeians served as soldiers, they had to leave their shops, abandon their potter's wheel, depart from untilled farm fields, and again serve as citizen-soldiers in the Roman army.
Regardless of whether plebeians were fighting for Rome, they were also still responsible for paying their debts. Unceasing military obligation and deepening credit balances owed to rapacious moneylenders caused wide-spread dissatisfaction, according to these tales. Exploitation of plebeians ultimately compelled them to join together and withhold their most valuable contribution: military service. Although the actions of the plebeians may have only taken place in the mythical imaginings of later historians who also lived through periods of popular commotion over debt and aristocratic power, these semi-mythical stories still have a worth. Tales of the early Republic and its army provide a framework for understanding imaginable types of popular resistance and collective action. We can certainly question the historicity of these secessions today. Still, it is patent that, in the minds of many Romans reading tales about the plebeians written down in the late Republic of the second and first centuries BCE, plebeian work stoppages and secessions were conceivable events. For those reading them, the stories were at the very least a plausible reaction by plebeians to the abuse of labor and power. The historical re imaginings of Rome's early days may also have proposed more peaceful reactions to displeasure with elites than had been evident in the days of the writers.
Today, we call the social, economic, and political clashes between plebeians and patricians the Struggle of the Orders. The likely fictional tales of Numa's early construction of trade associations served the ideological needs of Julius Caesar by justifying his ban on associations cast as not sufficiently ancient. Similarly, tales of the Struggle of the Orders may instead reflect the political rivalries and financial problems of the late Republic in the last two centuries BCE-rather than transmitting the historical reality of the fifth to third centuries BCE. As ancient historians today have pointed to, the late Republican competition between Roman politicians who supported traditional senatorial causes and interests, called the optimates, and those who supported more populist politics and political use of popular assemblies, called the populares, were perhaps grafted onto earlier, past conflicts between patricians and the plebeians. In this way, the patricio-plebeian conflict became an "ideological weapon."
Many of the issues mentioned in these histories would have also gripped contemporary readers in the first century BCE-and been quite familiar from their current lives. Popular struggles over debt, credit, and usury rates in the years after 49 BCE had pushed Caesar to institute his own debt relief and credit measures in Rome. The debt problems that historians such as Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus reported on for the early Republic would have hit home for audiences just a few decades after the civil conflicts of the late Republic. Embedded within their myths were also moral warnings about the dangers of abusing regular Romans alongside a celebration of civil diplomacy over violence. At least in these quasi-historical imaginings, the early Republican plebeians had rejected the tyrannical ways of some patricians, organized themselves in secret, and collectively bargained by withdrawing from the city.
Our story starts with a Roman farmer and soldier deep in debt. In 495 BCE, the Senate voted for war against nearby Italic peoples called the Volscians.
But this time, not everyone was in support of this call to arms. At Rome, a destitute freeborn farmer entered the Forum and pleaded with the citizens gathered there to listen to his plight as a freeborn man forced into debt servitude as a result of going off to war. It was a story familiar to many, it seems.
Although he had faithfully served Rome in all its recent campaigns, he could not pay the taxes due on his farm. He also took out a loan after his farm was raided. When he could not pay back the loan, the man and his two sons were taken away by an unyielding moneylender and placed into debt bondage.
They were then beaten when the father refused to follow directions. Standing among the crowd gathered in the Forum to tell his story, the farmer threw off his clothing to show the lashes on his body for all to see.
It was in that moment that long-festering tensions and outrage began to boil over between the patricians and the plebeians. Dionysius derisively notes a madness that possessed the crowd at this time. This turmoil and the farmer's pivotal call to abstain from military service would eventually lead to the so-called First Secession of the Plebs the following year. Myth or not, taking a closer look at the motives, tactics, and achievements of this defining conflict in Rome's early, heavily mythologized past, we can see more than just threats of a strike and the animosity between two different social groups. Likewise, if we review the Struggle of the Orders alongside shifts in labor, economic networks, and demographic changes, issues of the late Republic come to the fore: systemic inequality, increasing biases against tradespeople and commerce, power concentrated among the few rather than the many, debt problems, and a growing suspicion of private associations that met under cover of darkness.
In the fanciful retelling written by the Greek historian Dionysius of Hali-carnassus, the public viewing of a Roman citizen and veteran beaten by a moneylender in 495 BCE so rankled the populace that many of those living in debt bondage due to their unpaid balances ran out of the houses of their creditors and joined in decrying the practice altogether. One of the two consuls for that year, Appius Claudius Sabinus, who was the founder of the patrician Claudii family, could feel the ire in the air. Although he had been steadfast that the Senate not succumb to the demands of the plebs, he knew when to exit a volatile situation. He fled from the Forum. Meanwhile, his co-consul, Publius Servilius Priscus, sent a crier to plead with the people not to riot. As a concession, he paused all debt arrests in the city until the Senate could decide the matter. But the fact was that neither of the consuls that year was seen as a defender of the non-elite people of Rome. Priscus rode the figurative fence on many matters prior. Consequently, both consuls were ultimately disliked by the many plebeians outside the senatorial circles of patricians.
In the same year, the Senate announced to the plebs that they should choose a consul from the two currently serving to dedicate the new Temple of Mercury in the southwest Circus Maximus. The senators noted that this dedicator would also be responsible for two other important charges: the city's grain supply and the setting up of a mercatorum collegium, a type of religious association of merchants to care for the temple and serve the city. Rather than give this precious charge to a serving consul, the people instead chose a centurion to dedicate the Temple of Mercury. The space was devoted to the god of commerce and dedicated on May 15. Thereafter, the Ides of May held a special place in the ritual calendar observed by Roman merchants and those engaged in commercial activity. The observance was marked with a sacrifice to Mercury and the god's mother, Maia. There were always links between commerce, religion, and associations. Likewise, the people's choice of a centurion over a consul to do the honor was a social comment on their current dissatisfaction with Roman patricians and the magistracies they monopolized.
In addition to the debates over debt slavery within the city, there was also a growing means for acquiring enslaved persons from outside of the city: war. In raising troops to go against the Volscians that year, Priscus then declared that all the male soldier-citizens who followed him into battle would be free from having their property or bodies seized by the debt collectors. He also permitted the division of spoils namely, enslaved persons, cattle, arms, and military stores among these soldiers when victorious in their battles, along with allowing the seizure of hostages from the Volscians and their allies. Sabinus, for his part, remained viciously jealous of Priscus. He ordered that these hostages be whipped in the Forum and beheaded for all to see instead of being sold into servitude for profit. Here we see both Livy and Dionysius contrasting the ways that those in power should rule through the use of the patrician exemplars. But the calls upon the military service of the plebs were not yet finished; they lingered into the following year.
The new consuls for the next year, 494 BCE, entered office and again tried to compel service from the rather exhausted plebeian male population. The nearby Italic groups of Aequi, Volsci, and Sabines were all in arms and had to be dealt with. For their part, the plebeians held numerous meetings at night to discuss the levy and continuing problems with debt servitude. Some met on Rome's Aventine Hill and others on the Esquiline, rather than in the Forum. Livy reports that these secret assemblies greatly perturbed the senators, who in turn blamed the lack of consular leadership and the idleness of the plebeians for their behavior. The senators appointed a dictator named Manius Valerius, which satisfied the plebeians, and ten legions enrolled. The dictator and his legions took on the Sabines, while the rest went with the consuls to take on the other groups. But after his later triumph in Rome, the Senate again refused to deal with remaining plebeian debt issues. Valerius berated the senators and then resigned to popular acclaim, while warning that mutiny was on the horizon.
The senators viewed the plebeians as still under military oath to serve and tried to regroup them to fight against the Aequi. Incensed and abstaining from the levy, the plebeians spoke of killing the consuls. The senators grew fearful that if the army were disbanded, there would again be "secret gatherings and conspiracies" of the plebeians. Ultimately the plebs chose to secede and to leave for the nearby Sacred Mount, a place three miles north of the Tiber, rather than serve as soldiers again. Business and activities in the city came to a halt, and tensions between the plebeians remaining in the city and the patricians only heightened. After the senators sent an envoy, a deal was worked out for the establishment of a new type of magistracy only held by plebeians, called the tribunate. The Senate agreed to their request, and the plebeians returned to Rome. There was also the creation of a new popular assembly that could create legislation, the Council of the Plebs, and two new plebeian magistrates known as aediles. Later, these aediles would become magistrates who cared for the buildings, roads, city games, and regulation of the markets. As accounts of the First Secession indicate, response through swift collective action was a pivotal bargaining mechanism during the Struggle of the Orders. It also provoked a fear that would last centuries among the senators. This elite Roman dread of night-time meetings, secret groups, and the potential for social discord in the late Republic seems infused like strong tea into the stories of the early plebeians.
Patricians and the Monopolization of Power in the Early Republic
The patricians largely monopolized Roman social, legal, and religious power well into the Republican period. Separation of church and state did not exist in the Roman mindset. Romans believed that the political welfare of the city and its people depended upon its relationship or pact with the gods. Early pontiffs were patrician protectors and interpreters of religion, law, and even time. From early on, the religious power to maintain the pax deorum (peace of the gods) depended on the city's elite religious associations or colleges, also called collegia. They had particular command over the ability to take the auspices from the sky. These religious colleges interpreted divine will through auspices, communicated piety to the divine through sacrifice, and controlled the religious calendar. Priestly collegia were also dominated by patricians in the regal period into the early years of the Republic. Only patricians could hold the top priesthood for men, the rex sacrorum (king of sacrifices). This religious official held no other magistracies and was the inheritor of the priestly power of the previous kings-a vestige of the earlier period of monarchy. He lived in a house along Rome's Sacra Via (Sacred Way). His patrician wife was the regina sacrorum (queen of sacrifices), with ties to Juno.
Below this priestly king was the head of the pontifical colleges, the pontifex maximus, who would remain a patrician until 254 BCE. The major priests who served the Capitoline Triad (Jupiter, Juno, and Minerva), called flamines, were also at the time patricians, as were those members of the college of augurs who read the signs in the sky. Elite women were allowed some participation through certain priesthoods and religious events such as one called the Bona Dea festival, wherein women worshipped the "Good Goddess." But even here, patrician families dominated. The college of Vesta-often alleged, according to legend, to have begun under Rome's second king, Numa Pompilius was populated by Vestal Virgins who took a vow of chastity for their thirty-year (or more) term. If convicted of violating the vow of chastity, the Vestals faced the customary punishment of being buried alive. This college lived in the House of the Vestals in the Roman Forum, near where the Pontifex Maximus lived, in the Domus Publica. The power of the patricians was constantly displayed through these public religious collegia, as well as via their covetous oversight of the calendar and in their occupation of sacred spaces in the city fabric. In addition to their monopoly on Roman religious leadership, patricians also held heavy sway over the declaration of war, election of magistrates, and the prosecution of debts at the beginning of the Republic.
What ultimately may have triggered the First Secession were issues of debt bondage and the actions of patrician magistrates. The early Republican system allowed an individual to put himself and even his children up as collateral for a loan and thus become "bound people" called nexi. If these persons were Roman citizens, their citizenship remained intact, but their labor stood in for capital with which to pay off their debt. The extortionate moneylenders in the fifth century BCE appear to have abused this system. But we should not think of this as solely a struggle between the rich and the poor. From the beginning, there were indeed wealthy plebeians who helped lead this struggle and ostensibly made it a conflict between orders rather than modern socioeconomic classes. Scholars today are often careful to use the term "social order" over the more modern concept of class. However, the Marxist theorist and ancient historian G. E. M. de Ste. Croix argued persuasively that, while battles between the plebeians and patricians were a struggle between two political orders, this ultimately masked the underlying, concurrent class struggle that lay within.
The Struggle of the Orders represented different things to different people, depending on their wealth level. Not all plebeians were destitute farmers, even if we tend to think of the plebs as a synonym for "the poor." The wealthy among the plebeians wanted the removal of the legal disqualifications and imposed ceiling that kept them from holding political and religious offices. To achieve this, they fought alongside the more economically underprivileged plebeians, who felt financially oppressed through systems such as debt bondage-men who were also exasperated during periods of military service that were well beyond occasional. Ultimately, the patrician Senate's refusal to advocate for the economically underprivileged plebeians induced a portion of the plebs, led by the more economically powerful plebeians, to do something often seen as overtly suspicious throughout Roman antiquity: meet under cover of night. Plebeians began their own nocturnal planning, undertaken in secret on the Esquiline and Aventine hills of Rome. These night-time meetings set the groundwork for acquiring protection in the face of magistrates and for achieving more political representation. They would also set a precedent for using physical withdrawal from the city as a means of collective bargaining: secession was now on the table.
Early Republican Power Abuses and Assemblies
In addition to the levy and to the monopolization of magistracies, abuses of power by patricians were also a central issue within the Struggle of the Orders. These abuses were underscored and perhaps hyperbolized by later historians as a way of moralizing and pointing out just ways to rule. During this conflict, we are told that Roman citizens began to demand and negotiate for the legal provision of a pivotal civil right to call on the support of the people if physically abused by a magistrate in the city of Rome. The power of a magistrate to enforce the law as it stood was called coercitio, the source of the modern word "coercion." The popular power to counter this magisterial right was then dubbed provocatio or provocatio ad populum. Today, we might call this the right to appeal to the people. Plebeians were also gaining power through their own magistrates appointed to protect them. Legend held that after the First Secession within the Struggle of the Orders, the plebeians instituted the office of tribune of the plebs. These tribunes oversaw their assembly, called the Council of the Plebs, and were themselves required to be plebeians. There were ten tribunes by 449 BCE. These officials were a route to political power for high-status plebeians. They convened the council, could intervene on behalf of plebeians, made legislation, and were sacrosanct. Perhaps most importantly, they had the power to veto actions of tribunes and other magistrates, as well as senatorial decrees. They also could intercede and stop a Roman from having to serve in the army if unfairly forced to do so by a magistrate.
In addition to the native plebeians, there were other groups growing within Rome as well. Foreign tradespeople lived and worked within the city of Rome as commercial networks expanded across the Mediterranean. Greek traders had already been present in Rome going back at least to the eighth century BCE, but their numbers had grown substantially by the early Republic. Near Rome's cattle market, called the Forum Boarium, Greek and Phoenician influences could also be found, particularly the Ara Maxima (Greatest Altar) that was dedicated to Hercules. Hercules was himself a Greek hero and god associated with commerce connected to the Phoenician and Punic god Melqart. Workshops point to the growth of production and wares at this time.
Rather than solely being domestic production spaces for metallurgy, ceramics, and textiles, artisan workshops grew up within and just outside of the city of Rome during the eighth to fifth centuries BCE. Together, this evidence points to a mixture of Greek, Phoenician, and Punic religion, trade, commerce, and culture influencing Rome's own cultural norms and political mechanisms at the time.
Despite concessions, the patricians remained exceptionally powerful, not only within the Senate but also within popular assemblies that made important decisions for the community. At the time of the First Secession, for example, the 193 centuries that made up the Centuriate Assembly stood as the most important popular assembly for making decisions within the state. To convene it, a consul and later a judicial magistrate known as a praetor called the assembly to vote on key matters of war, to hear capital appeals, and to vote on important magistracies such as the consuls, praetors, and, eventually, the censors who took the census. The assembly's meeting was announced by trumpeters, and it met outside the sacred boundary of the pomerium in the Campus Martius-the Field of Mars.
The Centuriate Assembly is a fundamental example of how group voting en bloc-versus the individual casting of a ballot for an individual vote-can endow a small socioeconomic group with disproportionate power. To put it mildly, the anatomy and voting procedures of the Centuriate Assembly were complex but are important to understand in order to unpack how elite Roman ideologies and principles became systemic. The voting structure of the assembly privileged land-owning patricians over tradesmen and the wealthy over the impoverished. It also enshrined a bias toward labor and commerce that would continue well into the later Roman Republic, the Roman imperial period (31 BCE-200 CE), and beyond. The modern democratic ideal of every vote carrying the same weight and influence was not at play in Rome's Centuriate Assembly. Although every century had one vote, not every century had the same number of men within it. Despite the name of "century" suggesting a unit of one hundred men, a century could have more or less within each voting bloc. Just imagine if ten men in a century had the same voting power as two hundred men relegated to another, lower century. Consequently, wealthy centuries of property owners who voted first had the advantage. Property and patriotism were inextricably linked by many elite Romans, who believed that the more property and wealth one had invested in the state, the higher one's level of concern for the welfare of the Republic. To many elite men, more property meant more commitment to the state. For how could someone without land ownership ever be truly tied to or devoted to a place?
Legislative Transparency and the Twelve Tables
In addition to clout via magistracies and many of the popular assemblies, patricians also controlled knowledge of the law in ways that helped them to maintain power-something against which the plebeians protested. The plebeians remained frustrated with the patricians' tight control over the creation of laws, in particular. It was further exasperating to them that the patricians controlled the interpretation of this legislation. After much haggling between the patricians and plebeians in the middle of the fifth century, a board of decemviri (ten men) was established in 451 and then again in 450 in order to publish a public and pivotal codification of laws called the Laws of the Twelve Tables. Both the laws and the stories that stem from the creation of this pivotal legislation reveal the biases against plebeians that existed in the early Republic. The famed laws were published on inscribed tablets of either bronze or ivory and placed outdoors for public reading (both aloud for others and to one's self) in the Roman Forum at that time. A later Roman jurist-that is, an interpreter of Roman law-named Pomponius would, in the second century CE, note that these tablets were displayed in front of the speaking platform called the Rostra "to make the laws more open to inspection”. Transparency and the public presentation of laws encouraged understanding among the populace, as well as critique. In 451 the first set of ten tables were, upon public assessment, deemed unsatisfactory. Another two tablets were then added in response.
The Laws of the Twelve Tables remained an important set of legislation to know within Rome and beyond. They stipulated trial procedures, spelled out the prosecution of debts and subsequent debt bondage, required women other than Vestal Virgins to have male guardians to oversee their legal actions, discussed property and theft, and listed many types of civil offenses called delicts (similar to torts). They also reinforced Roman elite suspicion of activities in the night-time, laying heavier capital penalties on stealing pasture land and crops by night. In respect to associations, these laws noted that members of voluntary associations called collegia were legally allowed to enter into agreements-as long as they were not counter to the public law. This may or may not have been influenced by Athenian attitudes toward such groups. We are told by a later Roman legal expert named Gaius, who wrote a commentary on the Laws of the Twelve Tables in the mid-second century CE, that the analogous Greek word for a collegium was a "hetaireia," the same word used in Greek for political clubs in Athens and elsewhere in the Greek world. The jurist also remarked that the Athenian statesman Solon had made an earlier pronouncement regarding such associations in the city of Athens in the early sixth century BCE. The statesman had announced that these clubs could exist if they did not go counter to the law. Gaius claimed that Solon's law had influenced the later Roman adoption of a similar regulation for their own city.
While the new Roman laws stated that associations were allowed to exist within legal limits, many other portions of the Laws of the Twelve Tables suggest already-evident fears of sedition and secrecy directed at those involved in illicit meetings of private citizens, even if there was a conditional allowance for assembly. It seems the eighth tablet had a section specifically out-lawing illicit private meetings that were called a coetus. The decemviri who drew up the Laws of the Twelve Tables were privileged men with fears surrounding the formation of political groups. The plebeian meetings that had led to the beginning of the Struggle of the Orders had already been occurring for over four decades. From this point on, the holding of possibly seditious private assemblies would increasingly become a source of dread and worry among Rome's ruling aristocrats, a worry reflected in later legislation. As Rome's population, empire, and private associations expanded greatly in the centuries to come, angst over maintaining political and social power remained characteristic of those at the very top.
The stories told about this time continue to moralize about the actions of tyrannical patricians. In the midst of this crucial publication of laws, a patrician from among the Claudian family caused a telling scene-one that once again exposed the disdain felt by some patricians for the plebeians. A patrician senator named Appius Claudius Crassus, who was appointed as one of the board of decemviri who had helped to make the new law code, refused to resign his post. But Crassus's disrespect for the plebeians went beyond simply refusing to give up his power on the board. He also viewed plebeians as persons to be controlled, coerced, and even enslaved, as historians in antiquity would illustrate through an anecdote about Crassus's dealings with a woman named Verginia. The patrician had laid his sights on the well-known plebeian woman and was willing to use any means to get her. Verginia was the daughter of a plebeian centurion named Lucius Verginius and betrothed to a former tribune named Lucius Icilius. Like most elite men, Crassus was a patron with many dependents called clients in a powerful system of Roman patronage called the patron-client relationship. He asked one of his clients to claim Verginia as the daughter of one of his enslaved women. This act would make her the client's property as well. The plan was then for the client to give her over to his patron.
The Verginii were only one of the many wealthy and highly esteemed plebeian families gaining notoriety and political clout from the early Republic onward. This is a major reason we cannot see the Struggle of the Orders as a class conflict in the way that Marx and Engels did. The historian Livy says Verginia attended school in one of the many ad hoc booths and tents set up in the Roman Forum for schooling during the day. Entering into the Forum, Appius's client, Marcus Claudius, dragged Verginia to a court tribunal over-seen by Appius. This was a conflict of interest, to put it mildly. Although there was a delay in the trial while her father rushed to her the next day, Appius ultimately ruled that she was the enslaved woman of his client. After the unjust verdict was pronounced, a crowd gathered around Verginia and her father, who were near the butcher shops on the northern side of the Forum at the time. Snatching a butcher knife, her father killed Verginia. It was to give her in his words her freedom.
The plebeian crowd collectively rushed to protect Verginia's father from arrest and ushered him to the city gate. While the women grieved her fate, the men, including Verginia's fiancé, used the moment to lament the patrician abuse of judicial powers and the need for a right of appeal to the people. Still wielding the knife and leading a group of four hundred civilians in togas, Verginius exited Rome to a hill about twelve miles southeast of Rome with a military camp. A mix of soldiers and civilians then marched back to the city and rounded up more followers as they went to Rome's Aventine Hill and occupied the Temple of Diana. As historian Lisa Mignone reconstructs, the plebeian soldiers and civilians marched conspicuously through Rome in a performance of nonviolence to occupy the Aventine in this secession. As she notes, "This military boycott constituted a sit-in." This meant that yet again, the plebeians were again on strike in 449 BCE.
The initial occupation of the Aventine did not move the patricians to action this time. Escalating the withdrawal, the plebeian protesters again retired out-side the city to the Sacred Mount to force the hand of the patricians. Their strike eventually forced the Senate and new consuls into approving the reinstitution of the plebeian tribunes and the resignation of the original board of decemviri. The consuls also passed a law making the plebiscites of the Plebeian Assembly binding on all citizens-but with the Senate's approval first. Increased documentation and transparency were a part of these senatorial concessions. Copies of the resolutions of the Senate, called senatus consulta, would now be archived in the plebeian-associated Temple of Ceres at the foot of the Aventine, overseen by the aediles. By withholding their labor and civic participation once more, plebeians continued to chip away at patrician power. Patrician control of information and access to law began to ebb, allowing increased plebeian access to legal processes and procedures. Knowledge was power, and the plebeians demanded that legislation such as the Laws of the Twelve Tables be made accessible to the people.
Artisans, Merchants, and Trade Networks in the Early Roman Republic
The first decades of the Struggle of the Orders indicate that the plebeians did not form a monolithic union or even a homogenous social group in terms of wealth, occupation, or status. Despite not being a monolith, they could, as the myths suggest, coordinate en masse or in large, efficacious groups, to lobby for their causes, to strike, or to boycott. Tales of the early plebeians have them engaged in a number of important strategies for the acquisition of their civil rights: nonviolent protest, physical removal to places like the Sacred Mount, the Aventine Hill, and later to the Janiculum Hill, and the physical use of insulating groups of plebeians to safeguard individuals from Roman magistrates in public-that is, a bodyguard. Centuries later, in the late Republic and empire, these methods became important to some groups of merchants and those engaged in commercial transactions in the mid-first century BCE. Yet their actions were much more violent than those of the earlier plebeians. The endorsement of peace over pummeling was perhaps one of Livy's key lessons in his histories.
As we have seen, much of our quasi-historical knowledge of the Struggle of the Orders is based on the exclusive narratives of later historians such as Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus, both writing in the reign of Augustus (27 BCE-14 CE). But if we go beyond the internal intrigue of early Rome and the possibly mythical stories that dominated the narratives of these historians, we can begin to use other sources of evidence, such as mentions of treaties and legislation, to see the expanding local and international commercial networks also developing in the early Roman Republic. These early commercial networks will later become important in our quest to sketch out the formation of occupational associations and evaluate their purpose, their reputations, and their suppression in Roman antiquity.
One place to look for evidence of increased economic networking is treaties. Around 509 to 507 BCE, Rome may have signed its first treaty with the Punic city of Carthage, a Phoenician colony within what is modern Tunisia. In his explanation of the tumultuous events of the Second Punic War (218-201 BCE) between Rome and Carthage, the Greek historian Polybius later recounted the numerous treaties between the two states in the early to middle Republic. Supposedly, the first was in 509, and others followed in 348, 279 or 278, 241, and 226 BCE. The treaty of 348 put Roman and Carthaginian traders on equal legal footing for trade and attempted to limit piracy. At the time, the Punic city was the more successful state economically and offered attractive access to the grain market for Rome. This grain market would remain of highest significance to Romans throughout its history.
Grain came at a premium and was a constant concern for Rome. Famine consistently plagued the city, and although the treaty seems more advantageous to Carthage, Rome signed it. The terms addressed Roman trade in the Carthaginian territories of Libya, Sardinia, and Sicily. It stipulated that Romans were not to engage in trade without a messenger or clerk present. Prices would be controlled by the Carthaginian state. In exchange, Carthage was not to harm the Latin cities already under Rome's control, engage in conquest within the region, or build any forts in the area. Grain shortages in 496 compelled the Romans to vow a temple to Ceres, later dedicated in 493. This building project would involve non-Roman labor. Pliny remarks that the first officially contracted Greek artists to be hired for work in the city of Rome were two sculptors and painters named Damophilus and Gorgasos. These men decorated and put Greek verses on the dedicated temple. The archaeological record reveals Greek artists living and working in Rome long before this, but like many legends, Pliny's story served as a neat, reductive way of connecting Rome to Greece's long history of artists, temple building, and traveling craftspeople.
Grain remained an important staple for all of Rome's existence. Perhaps in 508 BCE, in 492 BCE, 440 to 439 BCE, and many other times in the Republic's first two centuries, Roman magistrates and senators sought out and then secured grain for the populace of Rome. The Roman diet focused heavily on grain, and the commodity was often the impetus for trade, treaties, legislation, and eventually-associations that facilitated a supply chain. In the later Republic, the grain supply was the basis for the creation of more organized corporations of grain merchants, dock workers, barge runners, and other intermediaries who would transport it to Rome. In addition to international treaties with kingdoms such as Carthage, Rome also began to create agreements with its Latin neighbors. These accords secured the legal validity of contracts and reconciled differing legal systems. Such resolutions were necessary to protect the growing number of merchants and tradespeople. They also functioned to encourage exchange through protection and the upholding of legal agreements. This would later be termed the ius commercii (law of commerce).
And yet property still trumped commerce as a source of prestige in Roman culture. As we saw with the structuring of the Centuriate Assembly, elite male Romans advocated for an intrinsic virtue tied to agriculture and the ownership of property. Farming one's own land was venerated above business by elites in public and in literature, but this only meant that commerce was undertaken more covertly by people like senators and other elites. In a more clandestine and indirect manner, senators often instrumentalized clients, enslaved persons, and agents to do their business dealings. Similar to elite Greek views expressed in the works of Aristotle and Xenophon, Roman philosophers and wealthy statesmen of the late Republic often looked down on trade and manual labor as "banausic"-a pejorative term used for those who practiced the "illiberal arts" of craft production. For elitist ancient writers, the term was frequently connected to slavery and to a disreputable need to earn wages.
Rome was not the only culture that sneered at manual labor. We can see this bias at work elsewhere, in the classifications of the various types of people in Mediterranean societies created by authors such as the Greek historian Herodotus. In his Histories, written circa 426 to 415 BCE, he remarks that there was a commonly held disdain for craftspeople. The exception to this social scorn was in the highly commercial city of Corinth-a great producer of pottery, textiles, olive oil, and stone where the least amount of stigma was placed on them. Herodotus observed a common contempt connected to artisans across the Mediterranean: I have noticed that in Thrace and Scythia and Persia and Lydia and among nearly all the barbarians, those citizens, along with their offspring, who learn technical skills are held in less honor than the rest of the people, and those who have the least to do with handi-crafts, especially those men who are free to practice exclusively the art of war, are highly honored. Manual laborers were essential workers, but not always respected ones.
The ability of artisans to serve as soldiers was also a question in the Republic. Livy would later comment that, when faced with war against the Gauls in 329 BCE, the two Roman consuls, Lucius Aemilius Mamercinus and Gaius Plautius, had chosen to conscript a lesser pool of men for service in the Roman army. my. When the consuls entered office, they raised an army that, to Livy's explicit shock, even included a mass of workmen and sedentary artisans. This was a group that, to the historian, was the least suitable for military service. To many elite literati of antiquity, key Roman virtues of masculinity, honor, and patriotism stemmed from owning land, not from trade or dependence on wage labor. Correspondingly, we will see that later occupational associations made up of artisans and tradespeople were not often cast in a favorable light in Roman literature, especially when they assembled for a political cause.
Roman literature created a mirage of anti-commercial attitudes and written biases against tradespeople that can obscure the reality of Rome's under lying, active participation in trade networks since its very inception. Rome's stories of the regal period held that it was one of its legendary kings who had helped Rome to acquire the area that would become Ostia, Rone's port, eleven miles to the west. Rome sat inland along the commercial ventricle of the Tiber River, which carried barges, tradespeople, and wares back and forth along the waterway-this in addition to the network of roads that led into and out of the city. Despite a law passed in 218 BCE that tried to keep senators and their sons from engaging in maritime trade by barring them from owning ships that could hold over three hundred amphorae, we know that senators tried hard to keep their reputations free of the stain of commerce. They used proxies and back channels to continue to participate in commerce, since trade was seen as rather déclassé among senators. Literature and historical accounts may have cast Rome as originally growing from a village of farmers led by Romulus, but make no mistake: it was always a city of trade and exchange as well.
In addition to the maritime networks expanding at this time, the Italian peninsula was a vibrant mélange of peoples and languages in the sixth to fourth centuries BCE, from the Etruscans, to the Oscans, to the Greeks of Magna Graecia, to the Celtic peoples to the north in the Po Valley. As Elena Isayev has recently emphasized, there was regular migration, mobility, and urbanization from below at this time, one particularly engaged in by groups of artisans, traders, elites, and many others in Italy. This culture of everyday movement continued until Rome orchestrated a more centralized control of migration from above in the late third century BCE. And yet Roman and Greek historians often characterized migrations as being more abrupt waves, applying ethno-stereotypes and markers of difference provided by food, beverages, or customs as a way to create cultural binaries-that is, seemingly opposing differences between Greco-Romans and the "other."
Cultural mixing is also revealed through contemporary inscriptions that offer firmer evidence than later, quasi-mythical histories. They indicate that at least since the seventh century BCE, Celtic groups had a presence in northern Italy. Recent studies suggest that these settlements may have increased in number around 550 to 540 BCE, with more groups crossing over the Alps and settling in the Po Valley beyond. Unlike the literary accounts, the archaeological record reveals ongoing interactions rather than distinct waves of Celtic migration and disruption. Trade then encouraged this steady intermingling of cultures further. From Celtic settlements in modern Austria also came a pivotal commodity: salt. This was an important product to Romans, one that, going all the way back to the first years of the Republic, the government had at times taken over from private sellers, when there was a need to give it to the populace at a lower price. Celtic merchants also trafficked in Baltic amber and many other luxury goods and traded for things like ceramics and amphorae of wine.
Although Gallo-Celtic groups were often characterized by later Greco-Roman sources such as Livy, Plutarch, or Dionysius of Halicarnassus as more "primitive" peoples displaced by hunger, discord, or overpopulation, in actuality Gallo-Celtic groups in Italy were accomplished merchants who in the fourth century BCE looked to expand southward. After Rome's conquest of the Etruscan stronghold of Veii in 396 BCE, the Gallic soldiers saw their chance. Meeting at the junction of the Allia and Tiber rivers, just eleven miles north of Rome, they defeated the Romans at the Battle of Allia. As Livy notes, the defeat on July 18 of that year was so devastating that the Roman fasti maintained the date as nefas (inauspicious), banning public and private business transactions on that day. Just as they were suspicious of nocturnal meetings and illicit assemblies internally, elite Romans would continue to be skeptical of both tradespeople and the influx of certain foreigners coming into their city in the centuries to come.
Around 390 or 387 BCE, the Gauls infamously sacked the city of Rome.
It was a generational trauma that would be mentally and physically remembered by Romans for centuries to come. Rome would not be sacked again until 410 CE. What is less emphasized about the time thereafter is not just the animosity toward the Gauls that continued for centuries to come, but also the fact that groups of laborers helped remake Rome and particularly its walls within a decade-at a high economic cost. The Republican walls, called the Servian Walls, after Rome's sixth king, were begun at this time. In that moment, the seven-mile-long fortification and ditch became much like the much larger Aurelian Walls begun many centuries later in 271 CE-Rome's largest monument. The walls were an investment in the city and a testament to the growing professionalization of Rome's military. The walls also reveal Rome's increasing reliance on organized labor forces pulled both from the citizenry and from the burgeoning enslaved population.
The organization of workers for these new walls provides a window into Rome's labor supply at the time. In the mid- to late fourth century, the labor landscape of Rome and Italy was shifting drastically. There was, however, one major change: during this time, debt bondage began to decrease as Rome's conquests brought in more enslaved captives. As archaeologist Seth Bernard has proposed, a mix of corvée (that is, compulsory laborers from the citizenry) and enslaved workers filled the ranks of the skilled and unskilled teams used to build the wall-all males ages seventeen to forty-five and numbering 16,300 to 32,000 in total. These unpaid workers were compelled, as Bernard argues, through a complex mix of coercion, debt, obligation, and taxation to create Rome's new city walls. Enslaved persons also factored in. Newly enslaved Veians may have quarried the stone for transport to Rome. The multiyear, forced devotion of civic funds and people to the project then had broader consequences, possibly causing an economic stagnation that would drag down the mid-fourth-century BCE economy.
During the fourth century BCE, the Struggle of the Orders also continued to drag on. The differences between plebeians and patricians further eroded, even as other markers of social difference increased. The conflict was never about freedom and justice for all, but rather about providing power to plebeians with means. A series of laws in 367 BCE had already put limits on usury and the holding of public lands by wealthy Romans. Plebeians also became eligible for certain priesthoods and the consulships. Throughout the second half of the fourth century BCE, the plebeians continued to win more representation through magistracies both old and new. Debt bondage also decreased as a threat to the plebeians. The practice was effectively abolished for free Roman citizens in 326 BCE or 313 BCE by a law called the lex Poetelia Papiria. This liberated Roman citizens even further from the threat of bondage themselves, even as they enslaved others at an ever-alarming rate. Chattel slavery rather than debt bondage would be a defining feature of labor issues and organization in the middle and late Republic.
Labor Changes at the End of the Struggle of the Orders
In Rome within the late fourth century BCE, there were also increasing concerns about another group: manumitted persons (previously enslaved persons) in Rome called liberti, Legislation concerning the taxing of manumission at the time points to the fact that manumitted persons were a growing social order. These men and women entered society with the rights of Roman citizens, but with limits on their ability to hold office. As with all Roman women, manumitted women also could not vote. Liberti retained legal and social obligations due to their patron even after manumission, and often endured a social stigma stemming from their earlier enslavement. The increasing roles played by these manumitted persons are glimpsed at in the waning decades of the Struggle of the Orders.
At this time, a former scribe and libertus brought transparency to the inner workings of the secretive Roman pontifical associations through a rebellious act of what might be called vigilante justice. The scribe's name was Gnaeus Flavius, and as Cicero would later remark, he pierced the eyes of crows [that is, outwitted those in the know] and published the calendar of court days to the people and in this way stole the knowledge of the legal calendar from the astute legal experts. The legal calendar marked out which days were either good or bad for legal action. Even two hundred years after Rome had become a republic, this calendar was still overseen by a small coterie that made up the collegium of pontiffs. The incident indicates that the Struggle of the Orders was about diffusing power to plebeians through their collective actions, but it was also about publishing information for public knowledge.
Toward the end of the legendary conflict between plebeians and patricians, the potent religious collegia finally became integrated. Through the advocacy of the plebeian tribunes, the two major priestly colleges ultimately allowed plebeian pontiffs and augurs by increasing their overall numbers in 300 BCE. But the struggle was not completely over; there was one last strike to be waged. In 287 BCE, the final secession of the plebeians allegedly took place over the very issue that had begun it: debt. Although details are murky, Pliny the Elder and a later epitomator of Livy note that the plebeians left for the Janiculum Hill across the Tiber, a space altogether outside the city walls, to protest the handling of debts. They were once again leveraging their demographic power through physical withdrawal. A plebeian dictator, Quintus Hortensius, was elected to deal with the crisis. He passed the law known as the lex Hortensia, which made the plebiscites passed in the Plebeian Assembly binding on all Romans, without the need for the Senate's approval. After between three and five plebian secessions (depending on the historian writing), the Struggle of the Orders was over.
Conclusions from the Struggle of the Orders
What is fact and what is fiction about early Rome? Examination of the quasi-mythical tales of the Struggle of the Orders alongside archaeological evidence for Rome's social, economic, and labor transformations during its first few centuries as a republic do not provide many concrete answers. The stories do point to the myriad, real prejudices held by elite and propertied Romans in a highly stratified society increasingly engaged in commerce, ex-change, and the intermixing of peoples from outside of Rome. This lore surrounding the early plebeians may also indicate at least the potential of collective action, secession, and peaceful strikes as bargaining tools in ancient societies, at least by the time of the late Republic, when many of these stories were written down. These collective memories of Rome's early days may also be viewed as moralizing tales that encouraged more nonviolent negotiation tactics over the civil violence engaged in between optimates and populares that we will soon discuss. Even if the early stories about the Republic are largely mythical, they taught core moral lessons and transmitted at least some hint of plausible, collective social actions to later Roman audiences.
What we can state definitively is that the success of the plebeians and the end of the formal Struggle of the Orders in 287 BCE did not magically transform Rome into a democracy. Rome remained a city and a society ruled by an oligarchy that outwardly displayed prejudices against trade. Now that oligarchy just had more wealthy male plebeians at the helm. While these men achieved greater parity with the patricians at Rome, social inequality, slavery, and a distinct xenophobia directed toward certain cultures and foreign groups expanded. As the next chapter examines, private associations of tradespeople and artisans also began to form and increase during these pivotal last three centuries BCE. This growth in associations happened first in the eastern Mediterranean, so as to navigate new commercial networks and provide things like entertainment and food more easily.
Tradespeople in the Italian peninsula and Rome also began to create small associations at this time. Some inscribed their existence into the historical record through inscriptions in stone or contracts written on papyri. In Italy, there were also involuntary associations of enslaved persons called familiae created by enslavers that increased in number within Italy. As the next chapter explores, at various times in Sicily and in the Italian peninsula, some of these groups realized the distinct advantages of collective action-acting together and leaning on prior organizational structures-as a tactic for breaking free from human bondage altogether. Rather than withdrawing from Rome to bargain for their rights and representation, as the plebeians may have, groups of enslaved workers in the late Republic would use their organizational skills to resist their captors and rebel against the Roman state. They did this through careful planning, strong leadership, and collective might that converted their prior labor organization in bondage into a weapon for coordinated action.
CHAPTER 2
We Are Spartacus: Labor and Resistance in the Late Republic
In the late republic, a gladiator from Thrace named Spartacus commanded a highly organized revolt of enslaved persons against Rome from 73 to 71 BCE. This was no small rebellion. Although the numbers given by ancient sources are often problematic to trust, they note that Spartacus commanded a staggering number of soldiers: between 70,000 and 120,000 at the rebellion's height. It is no surprise that from Karl Marx to modern movies, the story of Spartacus has captivated audiences. However, to understand the mechanics and logistical success of this impressive resistance to Rome, we first need to appreciate the shifting status of labor and its organization in Italy at the time. We must also situate Spartacus and his rebellion within the context of the expanding trade networks, burgeoning occupational associations, and forced organization of enslaved persons in the Mediterranean. The Third Servile War (73-71 BCE) led by Spartacus did not occur in a vacuum. It was a product not only of changes in the number of enslaved persons within the Italian peninsula, but also an increasing realization among free and unfree peoples of the power of collectives.
In the middle to late Republic (c. 300-31 BCE), many variant types of occupational and commercial associations emerged in response to the Hellenistic empires and then to the Roman one. They relied both on free and unfree workers, organized either voluntarily or involuntarily into their own groups, for a range of purposes. In the case of the Third Servile War led by Spartacus, he drew on the close internal bonds formed previously by enslaved associations called familiae, in order to spark a resistance that would conjure a quite real fear in the heart of many elite Romans. Looking at the three Servile Wars of the late Republic underscores the capacity for ancient enslaved persons to organize and resist bondage in antiquity. But under-standing earlier labor organization draws attention to the fact that leaders of the Servile Wars may have productively drawn on already-existing corporative structures and associative bonds to aid in their epic-and coordinated-struggle for freedom.
Entertainment Associations and Collective Bargaining
Associations were important mediators embedded in and often facilitating the networks that criss-crossed the Mediterranean and beyond. In the eastern Mediterranean, we can recognize this growth in associations particularly within the burgeoning trans-Mediterranean entertainment industry. Due to the popular hunger for theatrical entertainment and religious festivals that flourished after the death of Alexander the Great in 323 BCE, there was expedited development and patronage of associations of elite theatrical performers, which may present the earliest parallel to today's trade unions. In the Italian peninsula and Rome as well, associations of scribes, actors, and poets would also form to provide music, present performances, and exhibit theatrical shows for the growing calendar of annual festivals enjoyed by the people. This tendency to create groups and to rely on one's association was a social feature of the era. And the affinity for traveling entertainment troupes that began to gain steam at this time only encouraged the trend.
In the western Mediterranean during the second century BCE, there is an increase in evidence for other types of professional associations as well. Groups of cooks banded together to provide culinary services for hire in the marketplaces of ancient cities. Professional bakers allegedly were brought to the city of Rome in 168 BCE. The increase in Roman imperialism in the East and the massive influx of enslaved labor to Rome and the Italian peninsula was due to Rome's conquests and the fact Romans had no qualms with enslaving the conquered. There was thus an increasing reliance on forced corps of enslaved familiae in addition to voluntary associations. These organized "families" were associative units structured from above by enslavers and used to work on farms, to function as shepherds in places like Sicily, to perform domestic functions, and even to participate in a new form of popular entertainment gripping the city of Rome from the mid-third century BCE onward: gladiatorial combat. This intensifying system of both voluntary and involuntary associations within the Roman economy began to provide an underlying associative framework for many workforces laboring in the Mediterranean.
Associative changes were not the only ones afoot in Rome and Italy. Eastern conquests also brought waves of new peoples, goods, and religious beliefs to the city. This was, at pivotal times, met with a reactive xenophobia that impelled elite Romans to try and safeguard traditional ideals and religion. New legislation limited certain types of worship of foreign cults, modifying the freedom of assembly by certain groups. In 186 BCE, the Roman state would eye with suspicion the popularity of the worship of Bacchus and the connected religious associations that formed to worship this god of wine and drunkenness. The subsequent senatorial ban on Bacchic rites and the gathering of his worshippers is an instructive moment. Here we can start to outline how elite Romans began to react legally to their reservations surrounding nocturnal activities, foreigners, and any possibility of popular discord. Anti-assembly legislation would-well into the high empire-be recurrently deployed, to maintain state control from above by deactivating the private associations formed from below.
If we look to the Greek world for a view of new associations, the earliest professional organizations that we might view as analogous to the modern labor union were formed by entertainers connected to the theater. Their development was driven in part by high demand: in the earlier fifth and fourth centuries BCE, there had been a popular clamor for Greek dramatic performances of tragedy, comedy, hymns to Dionysus called dithyrambs, and other types of dramatic performances that were being held on growing festival circuits where theatrical performances often were staged. Although cities had long contracted with well-known individual actors to perform dramatic works at their local festivals, the early decades of the era we call the Hellenistic period (323-31 BCE) in the East saw the banding together of performers for collective action, as a means of ensuring that favorable, secure working conditions were established as they traveled to various cities to perform. The essential function of this labor association was to fight for and improve the rights and pay of its members.
By the early third century BCE, groups called the technitai (practitioners) of Dionysus, in particular, had established formidable associations, often referred to today as acting troupes, that fiercely advocated for their members. Contracts for the practitioners of Dionysus often came with what we might today call artist riders that listed their demands and secured their places on a festival circuit that wound throughout the Greek world and part of the Roman one. These unions of performers were particularly visible where rulers, such as the Ptolemies in Egypt, acted as their patrons. In this way, these groups were different from modern labor unions: powerful monarchs often used the fame of these performance troupes to their own advantage by advertising their patronage of them at festivals. This also demonstrated how state or monarchial patrons could work with associations to provide entertainment to the people.
The professionalization of the entertainment industry increased during the Hellenistic age and transformed the organization of entertainers, musicians, costumers, scenery-makers, and eventually athletes into popularly known workers in a burgeoning business sector. This important associative network continued well into the late Roman period. Popular demand for actors and performers at festivals ranging from the Soteria of Delphi to the Dionysia of Samos to the Ptolemaia in Alexandria drove these professional performers to create independently organized associations often called koina or synodoi. Some ultimately united as practitioners called technitai. These groups later spread to Magna Graecia in southern Italy and to Sicily, influencing the organization of the entertainment industry in Rome as well.
What made these ancient quasi-unions different from other associations at the time? According to contracts and agreements established through letters and often published as copies on inscribed stone, itinerant technitai could secure special dispensations. This included asylum rights that prevented one from being seized, or freedom from taxes. Foreign travelers needed protections in the ancient Mediterranean, and these unions of entertainers often used elected secretaries to write to and work with assemblies in local cities, festival organizers, and the monarchs who required their services. While many independent groups formed private labor unions, an increasing number of wealthy Romans also saw the compulsory organization of enslaved labor into groups as a means of satisfying the growing demand for a new type of entertainment gripping Italy: gladiatorial matches.
Even today, traveling entertainers continue to desire representation and collective protection from exploitation. In 1939, the American Guild of Variety Artists (AGVA) was founded to protect touring American actors, dancers, and performers on the circuit of traveling variety shows. This labor union grew out of the public demand for burlesque and variety shows as well as the need to protect stripteasers, dancers, and performers who were forced to endure long work weeks for low wages. Today, the AGVA continues to help with contracts, set wages, specify work conditions, set up secure travel and publicity, offer health benefits, and provide a number of other member services. Since antiquity, the entertainment industry has had a unique popular leverage that often makes work stoppages more successful. Gaining the support of the people by depriving them of popular entertainment until demands are met was-and still is a viable labor tactic for entertainment and sports groups.
Like many ancient associations, the technitai of Dionysus were highly systematized and hierarchical. These organizations relied on their own elected officials and internal magistracies. The titles for the magistrates of the technitai, such as archon, often imitated the magistracies of the Greek polis and provided internal prestige and reputation. They had their own protocols, guidelines, and officers, and often another trait common to premodern associations in particular: a religious component. The technitai had ties to Dionysus, the Greek god of wine and patron of the arts, as well as to Pythian Apollo. Although inscriptions often focused on this religious element, scholars have emphasized that the principal function of the secretaries of the technitai was business. As Mali Skotheim has reconstructed, the primary task of these groups was risk mitigation, since, as professionals moving from place to place, they were "legally and financially vulnerable." Many technitai maintained extensive archives of correspondence and had libraries to maintain and prove their legal rights, enforce contracts, and perpetuate their knowledge base. As we will see later for compulsory associations formed by the state in the late Roman Empire, knowledge organization and cultures of documentation within associations were methods for providing legal security, risk mitigation, and continuity over time. In the case of the technitai of Dionysus, these performers traveled widely and needed to make sure that they were protected and paid for their services properly and punctually.
Associations of Entertainers at Rome
Theater was not always a part of the Roman social scene. Livy notes that the city of Rome had its first theatrical performance in 364 BCE, following a bout of plague that had devastated the populace. Even after religious officials engaged in a sacred lectisternium - a kind of religious banquet intended to propitiate the gods, who were represented in the banquet by icons on couches-the sickness continued. According to the historian, the desire to appease the divine impelled the Romans to welcome their first public stage performances, which were allegedly introduced to them by the Etruscans. From here, groups of theatrical entertainers in the city only grew and became more visible, in part through their clubhouses. The actors in the theater were in Latin called histriones, and by the late third century BCE, writers, secretaries, and, at that time, poets were-along with the histriones allowed a special dispensation to meet within the confines of the Temple of Minerva on the Aventine Hill. There may be a continuity with the later collegium poetarum (association of poets) known in the second century BCE. Like many groups, this one had an official schola (meetinghouse). Theirs was within the Temple of Hercules and the Muses. This conspicuous clubhouse stood near Rome's Circus Flaminius in the Campus Martius. This special privilege of assembly within a sacred space, extended to the group by the Senate, came following the contributions of a poet and dramatist named Lucius Livius Andronicus during the tumult and uncertainty in the later years of the Second Punic War.
The long career of Lucius Livius Andronicus is a prism through which we can isolate and track many of the social and economic changes in Rome over the course of the third century BCE. The young Andronicus was born free. He was perhaps enslaved sometime after 272 BCE, when the Romans seized his hometown, an important port city in Italy's heel called Tarentum (modern Taranto). This critical addition to Rome's expanding Italic power came three years after the conclusion of a war during which the Tarentines had invited Pyrrhus, the king of the Greek kingdom of Epirus, to intercede on their behalf. This had resulted in the exhausting Pyrrhic War (281-275 BCE), ultimately won by Rome. In addition to Tarentum's well-known intellectual capital, stemming from its connection to Pythagoras, the city was famed for the production of expensive purple dye, pottery, wine, textiles, salt, and shell. fish. Following its subjugation, its valuable double lagoon port system became a boon to Roman commerce.* As Andronicus's praenomen, Livius, indicates, he was enslaved but then at some point manumitted by his enslaver. This was likely the consul Marcus Livius Salinator. Perhaps this was because he had earlier served as a professional teacher of Greek and Latin for the children of the family. The enslavement and eventual manumission of many Greek teachers who educated Roman students would become a common practice in the Republic.
At this time, transformations in other areas of Roman popular entertainment led to shifts in labor demands. Romans decided to use predominantly enslaved workers to fulfil the clamor for the new gladiatorial contests in particular. Although Romans had likely encountered them earlier, in Etruria, it was not until 264 BCE that gladiatorial contests came to Rome. In that year, Marcus and Decimus Junius Brutus, brothers from the famed Junian clan that had allegedly helped to found the Republic, brought three pairs of gladiators to perform for the funeral of their father. Valerius Maximus states that the exhibition was held in the Forum Boarium (the cattle market at Rome), while others locate it at the tomb itself. The much later, fourth-century CE source Ausonius notes that these were Thracian gladiators. This gladiatorial type, the Thraex, equipped with high shin protectors called greaves, a small shield, and a short, curved sword, was a common type." Gladiatorial types often assumed ethnic stereotypes and had distinct features that people could recognize.
It is likely, although not certain, that these first Roman gladiators were either enslaved prisoners of war or enslaved persons purchased specifically for funeral displays. This was a practice that would only grow in popularity in the coming years. Alongside these gladiatorial fights, spectacles began to be staged featuring persons fighting exotic beasts. These bouts represented and visualized Rome's expanding empire for the people of the city. For his triumphal games in 252 BCE, Lucius Caecilius Metellus arranged a battle in the Circus between a collective of operarii (workmen) of ambiguous status and either 140 or 142 elephants imported from Sicily. Rome increasingly relied on enslaved labor in its gladiatorial matches and beast fights (called venationes), the latter of which took off after 186 BCE. Eventually, owners of entertainment troupes began to organize these fighters into compulsory groups called familiae. Although these families of enslaved gladiators and beast fighters were created from above, as we will see, it appears that many within them created close bonds that generated solidarity and just maybe-allowed for quicker activation of gladiator rebellions in the late Republic.
Entertainment and Labor during the First and Second Punic Wars
The year 264 BCE was remembered as pivotal for Rome's expanding empire. The treaties with Carthage ultimately did not prevent the Punic sea power and Rome from coming to blows. In the First Punic War (264-241 BCE), Rome faced the Carthaginian Empire and its mix of mercenary and conscripted troops for the first time, predominantly on and around the island of Sicily. And Rome was victorious. Historians in antiquity pinpointed this moment as a transitional one for Rome. Picking up where the Sicilian historian Timaeus had left off, a Greek historian named Polybius commenced his own histories of Rome at this date. Polybius had experienced Rome's expansion as one of the thousand Achaean military hostages brought to Rome after the defeat of the Macedonian king Perseus in 168 BCE. As such, Polybius knew firsthand the waves made by Rome in the Mediterranean, and wanted to explain how it had come to gain such supremacy there.
During the First Punic War, Rome's armed forces metamorphosed and enlarged in order to take on its new foe. Rome's naval fleet went from a small number of ships used to fend off pirates or to transport delegations to a much more intimidating naval presence. After raids in 261 BCE, the Roman consuls of 260 famously ordered one hundred quinqueremes (ships with five banks of oars) and twenty triremes (ships with three banks of oars) to be built in just sixty days. But a key outcome of the First Punic War was not only more ships, but also more land, taxes, and prisoners. Rome annexed its first province, Sicily, and would eventually establish a magistrate called a praetor as its head. At this time, a province was more a magisterial assignment than a geographic place. Roman ships also increasingly imported grain from the island of Sicily. In the years following the First Punic War, the island began to pay taxes in grain (that is, in kind) that could help feed Rome's army as well as its citizens. This was done by tapping into a preexisting "agricultural tithe" system used by Carthage, particularly for the system implemented early on by the city of Syracuse." First Sicily and then the province of Sardinia-Corsica, starting from around 238 BCE, would pay import taxes in grain. Bread continued to be a primary state concern, as it had been for centuries.
Following the First Punic War, Rome also further evolved its own dramatic and literary cultures. In 240 BCE, Livius Andronicus put on Rome's first dramatic, narrative work in Latin for the games called the ludi Romani. This was just one of many written pieces we are told he composed. Andronicus also created a Latin translation of the Odyssey, in which he gave Odysseus a name that would be used for centuries to come: Ulysses. The incorporation of ritual games, new literary works, and performances into the Roman ritual calendar increased during the Second Punic War against Hannibal, Hasdrubal, and the Carthaginian army. Confronted by external chaos, Rome used the ritual calendar to create games and festivals to propitiate the divine with increasing frequency. This intensifying festival calendar also required more labor organization. The magistrates known as curule aediles took over the presentation of the theatrical ludi scaenici in 214 BCE, and new games called the ludi Apollinares were vowed to Apollo in order to invite his goodwill during the Second Punic War. In 212 BCE, four years after the devastating Battle of Cannae, these important games were overseen by the urban praetor.
Organizing games and ritual was not just the responsibility of curule aediles and urban praetors from above. If we look to the level of the vici (neighborhoods) of Rome, it is likely around this time that freedman magistrates called vicomagistri increasingly began to supervise their neighborhoods and their neighborhood shrines, underscoring the growing importance of identity and organization at the level of the urban neighborhood unit. People, and even whole occupational categories, were increasingly tied to these neighborhoods. The vicomagistri officially oversaw the preparations for the winter crossroads festival called the Compitalia. This annual celebration honored the very streets and intersections of the city. These magistrates could also be called upon by the state to arrange for sacrifices at the many local shrines during times of crisis, or to use the socio-geographic unit of the neighborhood for handing out subsidized grain to people. Over time, the social unit of the urban neighborhood came to function as a way not only to organize, but also to mobilize, Rome's populace.
A final result of the Second Punic War was that it brought changes to the status of Rome's artisan labor force. The use of enslaved labor from abroad became more pronounced at this time of expansion and imperialism. Polybius and Livy note that two thousand artisans from New Carthage, in what is now modern Spain, were sent to Rome to work as servi publici (state-owned enslaved persons) within what would be called the familia publica (publicly owned slave units). They were forced to work for the city, with an incentive of eventual manumission." But even after manumission, these freedmen remained tied to the state familia publica and often took the name of the town as part of their own names.
Manumission continued to be a coercive tool used by enslavers and the Roman state in the Second Punic War. In 214 BCE, eight thousand enslaved men were manumitted and given citizenship in exchange for their service in the Roman army, while that same year, elites were required to supply enslaved men to row in Rome's naval fleet. Likewise, Carthage was also a society dependent on chattel slavery and debt bondage. During the Second Punic War, it too drew on enslaved labor, purchasing five thousand enslaved men to row in the galleys of its naval ships. The use of enslaved labor in the Second Punic War is often overlooked in favor of valorizing the tactics of Roman generals such as Scipio Africanus, because it was indeed rare to enroll enslaved persons into the Roman military. Regardless, their largely invisible labor was a significant contributor to Rome's ability to win their second confrontation with the formidable Carthaginians.
Following the war against Hannibal, a number of state hostages began to be taken out of the city of Rome, where they were often held as political prisoners, and embedded in Latin colonies or Italian cities, as assigned by the Roman Senate." These political prisoners were accompanied by large retinues of predominantly African enslaved persons to attend them. In 198 ВСЕ, there was an insurrection in the town of Setia, forty miles south of Rome, by not only the hostages and their enslaved retinues, but also additional Punic prisoners of war. The hostages sent out enslaved men to seek support from other enslaved persons in the nearby Italic towns of Norba and Cerceii. The revolt seized Setia but could not expand its reach, because two enslaved persons arrived in Rome as informers to tell the praetor about the conspiracy; he then gathered an emergency group of soldiers, headed to Setia, and arrested the leaders, while also punishing thousands more.
When word reached the praetor that a similar revolt was being planned for the nearby city of Praeneste, five hundred men connected to the conspiracy were executed. Fears inspired by the influx of new enslaved persons-many of them with strong ethnic and linguistic ties to each other-spread to Rome. Night watches were instituted in the neighborhoods of the city, along with orders to keep hostages under house arrest. This denied the hostages access to assembly in public places. Prisoners of war were chained up in city prisons and watched closely. Enslaved persons of the same cultural background could be eyed with suspicion within the household. In the first century BCE, the agronomic writer Marcus Terentius Varro would even warn that grouping together enslaved persons of the same background could lead to "domestic quarrels" and problems controlling them." Fear and suspicion of enslaved persons meant that their actions, their gatherings, and their lives were often under surveillance by enslavers, even in a domestic setting.
The Status and Organization of Enslaved Persons in Italy in the Middle Republic
Slavery was a deplorable part of Roman society from its very beginnings. But there were acts of resistance against this system. Understanding not only its growth and impact, but also how it was organized, can provide some insight into how involuntary associations functioned from above and how later rebellions of enslaved peoples may have relied in part on this internal structure to organize defiance. In the decades after the Second Punic War, Rome classified large swaths of the population as property, and thus as commodities to be bought, sold, counted, and organized. In contrast to the modern democratic notion of equality before the law, Roman legal and judicial systems favored people with higher status. Legal penalties and punishments were often meted out based on a person's civic status, gender, and even reputation.
After around 286 BCE, enslaved persons were chattel governed by a property law called the lex Aquilia. In Roman legal thinking, the murder of an enslaved person brought injury to the property of another, and thus was a civil rather than criminal matter. Alternatively, killing a free man was classified as the criminal act of either murder or homicide committed through negligence. As with the public enslaved persons often used for the upkeep of the city's infrastructure and in many other urban positions, enslaved persons in households and on farms were also placed into involuntary groups of familiae. Those working in an urban or domestic space were referred to as the familia urbana. Families engaged in agricultural or pastoral labor, referred to as a familia rustica, were often herdsmen and agricultural workers.
The legal status of those born into slavery followed the status of the mother. We should not take the influence of this legal decision lightly. For instance, in early America, the Roman approach to dealing with the offspring of citizen men and enslaved women would have a huge impact on the southern colonies. In 1662, the Virginia assembly stated it was following the "wisdom of the ancients" by declaring that children inherited the status of their mother. As historian of the American South Catherine Clinton has noted, Virginians and many other southerners "invoked Roman custom to protect property interests" and, in the process, also increased the number of enslaved persons born directly into the household. Romans called a person born into slavery a verna. It was common for domini (male enslavers) to sexually assault and rape their own enslaved persons, whether male or female. A domina (female enslaver) could also force enslaved persons to perform or submit to sexual acts. Whereas Roman citizens' bodies were seen as protected, enslaved bodies were vulnerable and largely unprotected from abuse. Roman law enshrined and protected this attitude. The later social legislation of the emperor Augustus decreed that fathers could freely kill a daughter and adulterer if they were caught in the act. Meanwhile, their husbands could only kill the adulterer if the person was dishonorable, an enslaved person, or a prostitute. Enslaved persons navigated different expectations and consequences than Roman citizens, and their bodies were not treated as their own.
Occupational Associations in Italy in the Middle Republic
Associations often form in reaction to economic or social demands-or both. People tend to band together to address a shared need or common identity. We saw this in theatrical entertainments with the voluntary creation of technitai for staffing theatrical performances. Likewise, Romans would do much the same with the formation of involuntary gladiatorial familiae to fight in the escalating number of annual games. Associations were also formed in order to address new culinary tastes, elite desires, and commercial demands.
Like today, certain places throughout the Mediterranean world were known for specific foods and beverages. Just north of Rome lay the previously Etruscan city of Falerii, famous for its tasty sausages. The earliest Latin inscription for an occupational association was found on the capitol here, on a little bronze plaque once attached to a votive offering and dedicated to the Capitoline Triad of Juno, Jupiter, and Minerva. The second-century BCE dedication was commissioned by an association that had been sent to Sardinia. This association of cooks boasted-as ancient cooks often did of their ability to facilitate good living and entertainment during festivals, through their ties to the fire bestowed upon humankind by the god Vulcan. Dedicatory inscriptions offered a chance to show gratitude to the divine, but make no mistake: they also functioned as a medium for bragging about the status of people or their association.
In the Roman world, as in the Greek one, on special festival days, for dinner parties, or for a sacrifice, skilled cooks could be hired at the marketplace and the Roman Forum. In Rome, the first indoor market for the selling of meat and other foodstuffs such as vegetables existed by 192 BCE, if not earlier. This market was located at first in the northwestern portion of the Forum Boarium. As was typical across the Mediterranean, when people bought food-stuffs, they could also hire a cook to prepare them. Later inscriptions of the Roman imperial period note the existence of associations of cooks in Rome, often called a corpus or collegium cocorum, some of which had their own scribes and even treasurers." It is impossible to say whether the second-century BCE cooks of Falerii functioned like a modern union, but it is highly probable that as a collective, they were better able to set wages for hire and to establish themselves as an association that was directly consulted and hired for various festivals. At Rome and at the city of Praeneste, twenty-three miles to the southeast, other associations increasingly began to note their occupations, with a growing sense of pride in inscriptions, alongside their religious ties to certain gods. But not all Roman elites took kindly to the proliferation of new groups and their introduction of new and possibly disruptive deities.
Growing Xenophobia and Anxiety over Private Associations at Rome
After defeating Macedon in the Second Macedonian War in 197 BCE, the Romans infamously and rather falsely declared the Greeks "free" at the convening of the Isthmian Games the following year. The Greeks were in fact anything but liberated. The next century and a half would see Rome expanding aggressively into Macedon, mainland Greece, and Asia Minor through a mix of military campaigns and, as in the case of Pergamum, bequeathment to Rome. Along with the wealth that came with expansion into the eastern Mediterranean also came elite anxiety over safeguarding the ways of the Roman ancestors. There was suspicion of both the spread of foreign luxury in the city and of private cults that might undermine the Republic and interfere with its functioning.
This suspicion is evident from later literary sources, but also in the legislation of the time. From the Second Punic War into the second century BCE, Roman laws limiting luxury, reported by writers such as Aulus Gellius and Macrobius, appear to have been prevalent but rather impotent. The passing of these laws does, however, signal some Romans' displeasure with the changes in Roman society in terms of food, textiles, furniture, customs, and religion. The hostile rhetoric aimed at foreign migrants and the palpable anxiety of many traditional elites about the extravagance of exotic goods and services coincided with the growth of collectives of tradespeople coming into the city of Rome and Italy at the time. According to Livy, in 187 BCE, the first professional enslaved cooks arrived in Rome after Gnaeus Manlius Vulso won victories in the East in Asia Minor. The Romans had previously regarded these individuals as menial laborers. With the rise in importance of the Roman banquet at this time, cooking went from being denigrated as low-status work to being reclassified as an ars-a valued skill that was part of a more respected profession.
New associations meeting in the city of Rome were on the rise at this time too. We know of only a few who were recognized by the state formally and recorded in historical accounts. One of them was a result of Andronicus's literary services to Rome during the Second Punic War. In gratitude to him, an association of scribes, actors, and poets was allowed a special dispensation to have a state-sanctioned meeting place in the temple of the Roman goddess Minerva, starting around 207 or 206 BCE. They had a Latin name and a Roman goddess as their patron deity, rather than being labeled the technitai of Dionysus, as they were in the East. This was an attempt to Romanize this well-known union. As Erich Gruen has argued, their Dionysiac heritage was at this time shed in favor of a connection to Minerva "not because they required protection, but because the act signified the appropriation of Hellenic traditions for Roman national purposes." After all, religious piety was for the good of the state.
Romans had embraced some foreign cults in the previous century, but with caveats and hesitation. The Great Mother Cybele had been imported, along with her priests, from Phrygia in Asia Minor. This translation occurred during the Second Punic War against Hannibal around 205 to 204 BCE. The prophetic Sibylline Books had dictated that this action would happen at a time of crisis, and it was at first housed in the Temple of Victory on the Palatine Hill. But even then, her cult was tightly regulated from above. Cybele and her priests, the galli, were in many ways a necessary but highly contained foreign pathogen in the city. By law, Cybele's priests were not Roman citizens, were confined to their temple precinct, and could not convert Romans. In 191 BCE, Cybele's newly dedicated space was given a Latin title, the Temple of Magna Mater on the Palatine, rather than being called the Temple of Cybele. All of these changes in nomenclature and the civic limits placed on religious groups reveal some degree of unease with foreigners forming their own religious associations following the Second Punic War.
Elite Roman beliefs in the corrosive nature of foreign excess, residual fears of internal sedition from war, and a growing suspicion of burgeoning private associations at this time allow us to contextualize the Roman reaction to a new foreign group: the cult of Bacchus. In prior decades, the worship of Bacchus had spread north, from southern Italy to Rome. Livy says that a Greek priest brought the orgiastic Bacchic rituals to Italy, and that these included ever-suspicious nocturnal rites. These rites were inflamed by night-time indulgence in wine and feasts, which broke down Roman gender norms and ideas of modesty among the participants. Consequently, in 186 BCE, the consuls turned their attention to the disturbances caused by this internal coniuratio (conspiracy). Livy makes wild accusations of murders, poisonings, false wills, and other criminal behavior all coming from the same, as he terms it, officina (workshop).
In reaction, the Senate drew up anti-assembly legislation dubbed the senatus consultum de Bacchanalibus the senatorial decree regarding the Bacchanalia-and promulgated it throughout the city, its Latin colonies, and its Italian allies (called socii) in the Italian peninsula. The first step the law took was targeting physical assembly places by outlawing any meeting space for the worship of Bacchus, such as a temple, house, or clubhouse. An additional result was the banning of the group's nocturnal banquets, filled with wine and loose morals. Appeals went to the praetor, who then judged them with the aid of at least one hundred senators. Next, the law attacked the leadership hierarchies so common to all types of associations, by prohibiting men and women from serving as a head administrator or priest. It also abolished the group's use of a common treasury, internal oaths, and the coming together of five or more people for the rites. In his assessment of the Roman state's reaction, Jean-Marie Pailler remarked: "The Bacchic movement was reproached mainly for assuming de facto for itself an overall autonomy regarding the respublica, as if it aimed to function like a 'state within the state.' As Aristotle had also advised, Greek and Roman elites preferred groups that functioned to support the state and its laws, rather than ones perceived as giving individuals an alternative to it.
The Growth of Occupational and Business Associations Outside of Rome
While Rome grappled with foreign groups and new religious rites in the city, Roman troops won the Third Macedonian War (171-168 BCE) following the Battle of Pydna in 168 BCE. And while suspicion of new cultic rites might have been on the rise in the city of Rome, elsewhere, groups of opportunistic merchants and businessmen were themselves increasingly using the structure and benefits of flourishing collectives to their advantage for trade. Religious worship was a common feature for each of these new collectives, but underneath this pious veneer, many of them also profited in business ventures connected to Roman imperialism. An illustrative example of this can be found on the island of Delos.
In 167 BCE, Aemilius Paullus and his army sacked seventy cities in the Greek region of Epirus and took 150,000 captives. In the same year, Rome made the Aegean island of Delos a tax-free port, albeit under Athens's over-sight. Although some Italian merchants had lived on Delos in the century prior, Rome's removal of taxes opened the island up to an escalation in Italian, Roman, Syrian, Tyrian, and other merchants and tradespeople forming their own associations to facilitate commercial networks and trade with Asia Minor to the east and Rome to the west. Unlike the collectives of Hellenistic entertainers who had banded together to fight for fair wages and negotiate contracts, these were less akin to labor unions formed from below and more analogous to small business associations today.
On Delos and elsewhere, these merchant associations often had overlapping ethnic and commercial interests, as well as a focus on a patron or tutelary deity, like most associations in antiquity had. For merchants and businesspeople, this often meant worshipping the god Poseidon (Neptune to the Romans), Hercules, Mercury, or Apollo. The Tyrian merchant association on the island chose to worship Hercules-Melqart, the patron deity of Tyre, Similarly, the association of merchants at Rome had been attendant to Mercury's temple on the Aventine since the fifth century BCE. And in 112/111 BCE, the freedman magistrates of the merchant association of Capua are first noted by an inscription. Only a few years later, they are being referred to as the Masters of Mercury. Merchants and commercial agents not only worshipped the gods through their associations; such merchant associations also spread religious worship elsewhere as they traveled along commercial roads and waterways.
In terms of meeting places, many of the Delian associations used club-houses built specifically for meetings and banquets. Others simply met in a sanctuary at a shrine or altar, or congregated within a space at a marketplace such as the agora. These associations courted wealthy patrons who could endow them with money, status, and connections. The best known is the Delian koinon (association) of the Poseidoniastai (worshippers of Poseidon), who originally hailed from the Syrian city of Berytus (modern Beirut, Lebanon). These Syrian businesspeople were a group of merchants, shipowners, and warehouse-keepers who, in 153/152 or 149/148 BCE, honored their patron, the Roman banker Marcus Minatius." Having a wealthy banker as a patron might have gotten them better loan rates with low or no interest. In return, they honored him as one was supposed to in antiquity: with statues and events held in his honor.
What types of goods did these Delian merchants trade in? Italian associations of wine and olive oil merchants living on Delos proliferated, but so did human trafficking; the strategically located island was a premier site for the auction of enslaved persons. During the reign of Augustus, the geographer and historian Strabo noted that Delos could handle the selling of ten thousand enslaved persons per day, most likely in spaces such as the agora of the Italians. Cilician pirates often captured and brought enslaved Syrians and other peoples from the region to the island to be bought and sold at auction. The Delian population who lived and worked there was itself a mix of ethnic backgrounds and statuses, possessing memberships in various groups. A notable majority of the agents working on the island (persons often used as proxies for their patrons and enslavers in commercial transactions) who identified as Romaioi (Romans) were in fact either enslaved men or freedmen of Greek and Syro-Phoenician origins. The Delian economy and its success were heavily dependent on both slavery and the merchant associations that facilitated the buying, selling, and transport of human bodies across the Mediterranean.
Familiae, Resistance, and Organized Labor in the First and Second Servile Wars
Roman imperialism, rapid expansion, and the selling of captives were the engines behind the increasing dependence on slavery in Italy. Between 297 and 167 BCE, Rome reportedly enslaved 672,000 to 731,000 war captives. Another 55,000 were taken from Carthage after its destruction in 146 BCE following the Third Punic War (149-146 BCE), and an untold number were enslaved (and some slaughtered) during Rome's sacking of the Greek city of Corinth that same year." These enslaved persons were increasingly reassigned to a variety of occupations and positions while being sold and redistributed throughout the Roman Mediterranean. In Italy, they were particularly used for work in agriculture. On the island of Sicily, grueling agricultural labor on large estates and pastoral work as shepherds and herders lay ahead for many captives who had formerly been soldiers.
This influx of enslaved persons and their harsh treatment resulted in three large-scale revolts by enslaved peoples during the period from 135 to 71 BCE.
Today, these are known as the First Servile War (135-132 BCE), the Second Servile War (104-100 BCE), and the Third Servile War (73-71 BCE). The first two took place primarily on Sicily, and the third on the Italian peninsula. Scholars have long recognized that the massive number of enslaved persons coming into Italy during the first and second centuries BCE was a major catalyst for these episodes of resistance to the Roman state. But, as we will now briefly explore, preexisting labor organization, leadership, and collective action were instrumental to these uprisings as well. The speed and the success of these rebellions were, I suggest, in part due to an early reliance on and deployment of the social unit of the gladiatorial familia and its underly. ing corporative structure. This is particularly true for the Third Servile War (also called the Spartacan War). The enslaved familia was a basic cohort for cohesion, day-to-day organization, and-when the time came-permitted a coordinated action against its oppressors.
In 135 BCE, the first of the three Servile Wars commenced. A later summary of Diodorus Siculus tells us that the war was due to both the huge influx of enslaved persons and their harsh treatment by wealthy equestrian land. owners. Their bodies were habitually marked and branded by their enslavers, and they were given only minimal amounts of food and clothing on which to subsist. In response, these enslaved peoples organized themselves into what Diodorus dubbed miniature armies of brigands dispersed across the island, each working as bands. These enslaved shepherd-soldiers were not acting as inept mobs; they developed some sense of cohesion and established networks for communication both prior to and during the war. And it is telling that the epicenter of the nascent uprising was at the level of the household.
The start of the rebellion near Enna, in the central part of the island, was begun by the enslaved persons of a particularly brutal dominus named Demophilus and his wife. Likely acting as a familia, they chose as their leader a man originally from Apamea in Syria named Eunus, who belonged to another wealthy Roman. This group first rose up and killed Demophilus and his cruel wife (although sparing their daughter). Eunus then created a royal council that systematically armed six thousand to serve in his army. The bands of enslaved persons on the western coast chose a Cilician named Cleon as their leader. Each group took part in coordinated movements as separate but intentional units, as scholars such as Roberta Stewart have pointed out, before joining forces with Eunus at their head.st Ancient sources undercut Eunus's leadership by casting him as a charlatan cult leader who relied on religious devotion to inspire men to follow him through signs and miracles.
He did fashion himself as a Hellenistic king in the mold of the Seleucids through his choice of name (Antiochus) and by minting coins. However, to dismiss him as merely a charismatic magician and pseudoking disregards his organizational skills during the First Servile War and the rebellion's influence.
In Roman literature, writers cast the First Servile War's coordinated but unsustained success as a "contagion" and its rebels as a "mob" that had to be contained and then remedied. Not all Romans reacted positively to those who attempted to cure the situation by addressing its root causes rather than simply punishing the rebels. For instance, at Rome in 133 BCE, the tribune Tiberius Gracchus recognized the dangers of the buildup of enslaved persons on large Roman estates and attempted a reform that would redistribute public lands called the ager publicus, which had been encroached on and taken over by expanding, large farms akin to plantations. What began with the swing of a wooden chair leg ended with Gracchus and many of his supporters abruptly being assassinated in the city of Rome, and many of their bodies cast into the Tiber. Furthermore, literary accounts calling the First Servile War a "contagion" downplay the fundamental structural components and evident martial coordination we glimpse at in the sources. From the basic social unit of a single Sicilian estate and its familia, the movement expanded and created its own internal hierarchy.
At the end of the First Servile War, Cleon died in battle, and Eunus was eventually imprisoned in the central Sicilian city of Morgantina, where he died from lice. But their actions inspired others, particularly the synchronization of the revolt. Uprisings of enslaved persons at Sinuessa, Minturnae, Rome, and the island of Delos similarly troubled the Romans. In 134 BCE, enslaved workers in the mines of Laurium in Attica revolted against their overseers as well. The systematic gains made by Eunus's troops appear to have motivated others to undertake collective action and to resist their enslavement-a sentiment that posed a risk to the stability of the Roman state and its economy. This wave of imitative rebellions demonstrates that there was also a functioning network of communication bringing news of the events on Sicily to other enslaved persons throughout Italy and the Mediterranean.
Less than three decades later, from 104 to 100 BCE, a Second Servile War gripped Sicily. This occurred in a period of upheaval during which Gaius Marius served as consul for successive years, while Rome became distracted by a war to the north against the Teutones and the Cimbri. The Bithynian king Nicomedes rejected Marius's request for allies to supply troops to Rome, stating that the Bithynians were already being enslaved by the Roman tax farmers sent out to the provinces. In response, the Senate declared that Roman allies should no longer be enslaved. In Sicily, the praetor began to carry out these manumissions widely, much to the dissatisfaction of the owners of the enslaved who were being freed by the decree. The elite enslavers begged him to stop turning their chattel into liberti (freedmen). When a number of Sicilian enslavers approached the praetor after over eight hundred of the enslaved had gained freedom in just a few days, the magistrate listened to their pleas. However, the abrupt and illegal halt to the manumissions in Sicily caused widespread discontent and plans for a new rebellion among those who had hoped for liberty. The enslaved persons within the familiae of two rich brothers then banded together and killed their masters at night. In these origins of the Second Servile War, we can detect a focus on the conspiratorial elements that caused elite Romans such anxiety. We can also see the important role pre-organized labor played in these uprisings.
Much in the manner of a large association with its own set mechanisms for voting and electing officials, enslaved persons during the Servile Wars banded together and then replicated the structures of both the Greek polis and the Roman state, albeit on a smaller scale. Diodorus notes that, once the enslaved rebels in the First Servile War had reached six thousand strong, they formed a popular assembly that he calls an ekklēsia a term for the popular assembly in a Greek polis and, in later epigraphic and literary sources of the early empire, a label also used for certain associations and collectives. During the Second Servile War, the convened ekklēsia of enslaved persons voted in a king named Salvius who, in the style of Eunus prior, renamed himself Tryphon to evoke ties to the Seleucids and Hellenistic kingship. Later, about thirty thousand troops were trained and deployed, eventually joining with another rebelling group of enslaved persons led by a certain Athenion, whom Salvius Tryphon later detained and then released. Salvius Tryphon established his own capital, with a palace and advisors, at Triocala in western Sicily, where he adopted the visual signs of power accorded a consul: a Roman toga praetexta of the kind worn by senators, and lictors carrying fasces who preceded him.
Not long thereafter, Tryphon died after a battle. But the war continued, causing famine in the city of Rome. This was a potent reminder of Rome's dependence on Sicily's wheat for its bread supply. Egypt was not yet a part of the Roman Empire, and thus the city greatly depended on the island. Rome directed its ire at both the enslaved persons who had risen up and those communities in the East that it saw as the root cause of the uprising. Aaron Beek has argued that Rome in part blamed those in the regions of Asia Minor for the sedition occurring in Sicily, and sent Marcus Antonius (grandfather of Marc Antony of the Second Triumvirate) on a Cilician campaign to punish them in 102 BCE.5% The Sicilian revolt was finally put down by Gaius Aquilius, Marius's co-consul, in 101. Afterward, Aquilius tried to send one thousand war captives back to Rome to participate in the beast fights that were increasing in popularity in the city. In 104, an aedile had put on Rome's first beast fight with multiple lions, and fighting elephants would soon become all the rage in the early first century BCE. However, we are told that, to a man, the Sicilian prisoners committed suicide rather than perform as beast fighters for the pleasure of Roman crowds hungry for spectacles. The events at the end of the Second Servile War indicate that the growing appetite for organized games continued unabated into the first century BCE, causing an increase in the number of enslaved persons sold into familial troupes and trained within a flourishing new type of school: the gladiatorial training camp.
Collective Action and Mobilization under Spartacus
Roman accounts of the Third Servile War (73-71 BCE) reveal the convergence of socioeconomic trends in Roman society relating to slavery and entertainment with numerous elite fears connected to independent groups and sedition. This context set the stage for the last of the three large slave wars. Roman male elites continued to experience anxiety about the possibility of nocturnal planning by seditious groups-whether foreign cults or enslaved familiae that might undermine the established social order and the Roman state. At the same time, large groups of enslaved persons realized that, with proper organization and leadership, they could formulate, mobilize, and function as alternative states. And finally, an increasing number of enslaved gladiators were being placed in training schools embedded in the Roman country-side, eventually to be sold and deployed in games, in reaction to the growing demand for spectacles in Rome and elsewhere in Italy.
The "Spartacan War" checked all of these boxes. Almost two hundred years later, Plutarch's account of the war in his Life of Crassus notes that Spartacus was a nomadic Thracian. Thrace was the Balkan area west of the Black Sea, consisting of parts of what are now modern Bulgaria, Greece, and Turkey.
We are told that his prophetess wife came from the same background. She was said to be subject to a "Dionysiac frenzy"-a harbinger of foreign danger that certainly would have evoked the senatorial fears and actions taken against the Bacchanalia over a century before. Spartacus was brought to a gladiator training camp at Capua, a town in Campania in southern Italy, on the Via Appia. Training schools for gladiators had been located there since at least the second century BCE. These troupes, owned by Roman elites rather than the aristocrats of Capua, often performed in the Capuan amphitheater just beyond the walls of the city and elsewhere in Campania and at Rome. Spartacus's troupe, owned by Gnaeus Cornelius Lentulus Vatia, may have largely consisted of Thracians and Gauls. As will be discussed in the next chapter, Caesar later had a gladiatorial troupe of about one thousand gladiators housed at Capua. We are told that seventy-four to seventy-eight gladiators escaped from Vatia's school and, together, collected more enslaved persons from the surrounding ergastula (workshops). But what is it about the organization of the gladiatorial school that might have facilitated a labor uprising and escape like the one undertaken by Spartacus and his fellow gladiators?
There was a distinguishable hierarchy within ancient gladiatorial training camps. Troupes were run by a gladiatorial overseer stigmatized as legally infamous and thus legally restricted. He was called a lanista. These head trainers could also rent out the troupes of gladiators (called familiae) to any game organizer (called an editor) who wished to pay the price to put on games for the community. Gladiators trained and lived at gladiatorial training camps called ludi. In 2011, a gladiatorial training camp was found at Carnuntum in Pannonia (now in modern Austria), but there were many others in cities such as Rome, Pompeii, and, of course, Capua. As with other servile familiae and collegia, gladiators drew on them for a sense of identity and likely for camaraderie as well.
Gladiatorial troupes could be further subdivided into named decuriae. There were also more informal subunits within the gladiatorial familia. In the Ludus Magnus at Rome, four to five gladiators roomed together in a cell, much as the smallest subunit in the Roman army, a contubernium, consisted of a tent of eight men. Roommates and tentmates often formed close bonds. Although they were in compulsory groups, these troupes do seem to have been regarded with fondness by some of their members. A graffito from the Quadriporticus of the theater at Pompeii notes that the gladiatorial familia of an elite man named Pomponius Faustinus had signed it as a group. Similarly, in the second or third century CE, in the city of Smyrna in modern Turkey, a familia of gladiators did something associations often did: it set up an epitaph for a deceased comrade, in this case, a Thraex-type gladiator named Satornilos or perhaps Saturninus. Many gladiatorial troupes had internal magistrates and religious affiliations, just as voluntary associations did. Inscriptions indicate that even veterans of the troupe and those freed from slavery could continue to be associated with their gladiatorial familiae following manumission. Between 120 and 81 BCE, at Puteoli, not far from Cumae, a group of retiarii (a gladiatorial type who fought with spears and nets) made a dedication in stone to the god Mercury. The stone lists perhaps six magistrates, three of whom we know were freedmen. However, such troupes present a paradox. As Garrett Fagan has explored in his analysis of the gladiatorial training camp, the gladiatorial troupe is akin to an oxymoron, since it was "a community of trained killers who lived and worked together, only to turn their skills on each other." And yet, it was their close living quarters, organization into troupes, and coordinated training that likely made possible the successful beginnings of the Spartacan War.
The extant accounts of the outbreak cannot tell us much about whether a familia acted as one unit, but it does hint at the collective action of the whole ludus. In Plutarch's account, two hundred men originally planned to escape from the Capuan school, although less than half were able to. This is slightly smaller than the estimated size of the ludus as a whole in Pompeii, which likely held around 250 gladiators." Plutarch describes them grabbing knives and skewers from the school kitchen and, once they had seceded from the school, choosing three leaders. In Appian's account, the rebel gladiators take refuge on Mount Vesuvius, where they organize themselves further, with Spartacus leading and fellow gladiators Oenomaus and Crixus acting as his seconds-in-command.
As a former soldier, Spartacus knew that provisions and organization were crucial, but the suborganization and provisioning of the gladiatorial ludus likely informed his knowledge about many of the jobs he needed to create to arm and mobilize his troupes and conduct their early raids. We are told that Spartacus had weapons forged and supplies collected for distribution to his soldiers. He also stopped merchants from trading with them in gold and silver, only accepting iron and copper, because these metals could be melted down for weapons and armor. In his reconstruction of the Spartacan War, ancient historian Barry Strauss remarks that "[Spartacus] modeled his army on the legions, at least in some respects," and that insurgents seized upon the trappings of Roman power: military vexillations, eagles, and the fasces. Most analyses of Spartacus depict him as formulating a micro-version of the Roman army and state. Yet, more credit needs to be given to the preexisting and underlying group structures and organization of the ludus and how they shaped rebellions. It is this associative infrastructure that was also familiar to Spartacus, and that he was likely modeling as well. He may have drawn on the labor model organized within the ludus and then expanded on it to help organize his troops in the aftermath of their escape from the gladiatorial school.
In the end, after over two years of fighting throughout the Italian peninsula, Spartacus and his troops were defeated by the Roman army. In 71 BCE, the former gladiator took a spear to the thigh in battle against Crassus and his troops. His body was never recovered, but the Spartacan troops fled into the mountains and split into four distinct groups that continued to resist until only six thousand were left. The Romans took the remaining Spartacan soldiers prisoner and then crucified them, likely along the Appian Way. This mass crucifixion was used as a demonstrative punishment, intended to deter any enslaved persons or seditious groups that might be considering rebellion. It was a ruthless communication that Rome would not tolerate treason. The Spartacan War increased the already evident fear of internal sedition held by wealthy enslavers. It also convinced Romans that gladiators should be both legally and physically policed through a mixture of diminished social status and tighter guarding.
Spartacus and the Tumult of the Late Republic
In the Mediterranean during the middle and late Republic, popular desire for entertainment stimulated new types of labor collectives. Some were free and some were unfree. While a few, such as elite Greek performers, created associations for protections and collective bargaining that relied on the growing festival circuits connecting Mediterranean theaters, others, such as cooks, slave traders, and poets, formed their own associations to serve common religious, commercial, and social interests. And yet, as we have seen, involuntary associations also played a big part in the history of the middle and late Republic. The placement of gladiatorial training camps in Campania may have in part facilitated the outbreak of the Spartacan War and informed its early successes by providing a pre-existing structure of leadership, friendship, and coordination. The Spartacan War and the two prior Servile Wars that occurred in the second and first centuries BCE did not occur in a vacuum.
And yet, as the Roman associative fabric expanded below, unease grew above, principally at the level of the elites within the Roman Senate who were themselves also wealthy landowners and enslavers. For their part, they turned to legislation as a means of extinguishing the threat of social upheaval. The restrictive senatorial decrees concerning the Bacchanalia in 186 BCE and their tight oversight of foreign cults point to Roman xenophobia at the level of the Senate, while also gesturing to the shifting demographics and interests among the populace below. Tensions between social orders and between enslavers and the enslaved were pronounced at this time. And this was not just among Bacchic cults in Rome or in Campanian gladiatorial training camps. Dominic Machado has argued that in the Roman military at this time, there was also a notable uptick in Roman soldiers pushing back against their commanders through mutiny. Machado shows that the rise in late Republican mutinies by soldiers should be seen within, as he terms it, "a broader context of dissent.” Whether it was due to the Italian allies fighting against Rome for citizenship and rights in the Social War (91-87 BCE), the three Servile Wars, or the Republic's increasingly tense political competitions between powerful men like Marius and Sulla, all led to the same outcome: Rome was a society in flux. However, this flux cannot simply be cast as a contagion spread by a disorganized mob of rebels. These rebellions often relied on organized labor from below practicing methods deployed by groups in Roman society since the early Republic.
As powerful men competed for control of the Republic in its last days, regular Romans increasingly turned inward, to the collective identities offered by various associations to fulfill certain religious, economic, and social desires not being met by the state. These groups could be used for trust in commercial deals; to provide burial assurances in a society without universal healthcare or life insurance; or to create their own demimonde through regular communal events, such as dining parties, worship, and social interaction among members. As we will see in Chapter Three, during the last days of the Roman Republic, these new associations would also become key players in Roman politics-as both a source of fear and a font of opportunity for politicians looking to acquire manpower and protection.
Unease with collegia among Roman senators would only be reinforced by their political mobilization for violent ends in the mid- to late first century BCE, during the Catilinarian conspiracy of 63 BCE. It would then reemerge with the ascent of a man who would fully realize the clout that came from marshaling these groups as a personal militia: Publius Clodius Pulcher. Under Clodius's patronage, both Roman occupational associations and gladiatorial troupes would soon play a crucial role in the battle for control of the Republic being waged between competing political factions. As a result, the Roman Senate and its consuls would become ever more suspicious of the meeting of associations in inns and bars across the city. Many would question whether their existence was warranted at all.

Comments
Post a Comment